CONTEST
CompetedSMS
$3,000
This contest is closed.
Problem
We request previously undiscovered prior art including patents and non-patent literature (for example academic papers, technical descriptions, etc.) in English and foreign languages that can help invalidate claims 1 through 6 of US patent 8,295,805 (‘805) - “Real-time replenishment with electronic confirmation for sale of prepaid long distance.” The patent describes a method and system to provide electronic receipts via SMS for adding to or subtracting from value stored in an account on a server.
Specifically, the patent describes communication with a server which stores phone numbers, unique personal identification numbers (PIN), and associated balances for prepaid long-distance calling accounts. It describes increasing or decreasing this balance, and communicating a receipt in the form of an SMS message to the purchaser.
In particular we are looking for patent and non-patent prior art demonstrating this type of remote account storage system where the PIN is the same as the phone number for each account. Submissions could include documentation of any type of account storage system; for example credit card, prepaid mobile phone or long-distance, refillable consumer gift card, or any other prepaid-style account system with the relevant features. The questions below will help determine if a located source discloses all the desired features.
If you are new, see patent and prior art basics and tips for Patexia's prior art contests, and refer to the submission notes below. The best qualifying submission that recites the elements embodied in the questions listed below is guaranteed to receive the prize. The following questions will help you understand what we are looking for in this study.
Questions
The following questions will help clarify the contest and eligible submissions, and will be asked in the submission process. To be eligible for full prize amount, users should answer “yes” to all 11 questions, and indicate for each question where in the submitted references we can locate this information.
- Was the reference published before October 5th, 2009?
- Does it describe an account system which stores a phone number, PIN, and balance for each account?
- Does it disclose a user interface that accepts a phone number, a monetary amount, and an indication whether a decrease or increase is desired?
- Is the account’s PIN the same as the associated phone number?
- Does the user interface communicate with a server that receives requests to increase or decrease the balance of a particular account by an amount?
- Does this server then compare the phone number to a list of stored numbers?
- If the phone number is not found on the server, does it either create a new account to increase the balance, or indicate an error if a decrease in balance is requested?
- Does it increase or decrease the balance depending on the choice entered by the user?
- Does it then send an SMS message which contains an access phone number for using prepaid long distance minutes?
- Does the SMS contain the monetary amount added?
- Does the SMS contain the balance on the account?
Questions
# | Question | Value |
---|---|---|
1 | Was the reference published before October 5th, 2009? | 0 |
2 | Does it describe an account system which stores a phone number, PIN, and balance for each account? | 0 |
3 | Does it disclose a user interface that accepts a phone number, a monetary amount, and an indication whether a decrease or increase is desired? | 0 |
4 | Is the account’s PIN the same as the associated phone number? | 0 |
5 | Does the user interface communicate with a server that receives requests to increase or decrease the balance of a particular account by an amount? | 0 |
6 | Does this server then compare the phone number to a list of stored numbers? | 0 |
7 | If the phone number is not found on the server, does it either create a new account to increase the balance, or indicate an error if a decrease in balance is requested? | 0 |
8 | Does it increase or decrease the balance depending on the choice entered by the user? | 0 |
9 | Does it then send an SMS message which contains an access phone number for using prepaid long distance minutes? | 0 |
10 | Does the SMS contain the monetary amount added? | 0 |
11 | Does the SMS contain the balance on the account? | 0 |
Additional Notes
Additional Notes
- Submission deadline is February 28th (4 weeks from contest start date of January 31), 2013.
- All work must be prepared by a single researcher.
- The first researcher to satisfactorily respond to all 11 questions will receive the prize.
- Maximum of one entry per person allowed.If you were referred, the referral prize ($500) will be paid to the referring user from the total prize pool of $3000.
- Entries must be in English.Please make sure to answer all the questions and explain how we can find that in the reference.
- In case you are submitting foreign references, please provide a translation of key sections.
- If your reference has already been submitted by another researcher before you or is among the known references, it will not be considered for the contest.
- Please use “Ask a Question” to post general questions or feedback about the contest to the community.
- For specific questions, you can contact us directly by email at contests@patexia.com.
- All submissions are subject to Patexia's contest legal terms. Failure to follow these rules may lead to disqualification from the contest.
Known References
The following references are known prior art related to 8,295,805. Please do not resubmit them.
- 2001/0007983 7/2001 Lee
- 2007/0179974 8/2007 Cai et al.
- 2007/0244752 10/2007 Bayne
- 2008/0219421 9/2008 Enriquez
- 2009/0202054 8/2009 Wick
- US 6,044,259 Mentila et al.
- US 6,873,690 Moon et al.
- US 8,095,463 Hartmaier
- Aspan, M., “Prepaid Card is Linked to Auto Lending Device,” American Banker, March 31, 2008.Hauben, A., “Unique Opportunities in Prepaid Calling” the PrepaidPress; September 15, 2009.
- Hughes et al., “M-Pesa: Mobile Money for the ‘Unbanked’ - Turning Cellphones into 24-Hour Tellers in Kenya,” Innovations, Winter/Spring 2007, vol. 2, No. 1-2; June 12, 2007.
- Mas et al., “Designing Mobile Money Services – Learning from M-PESA,” Innovations, Spring 2009, vol. 4, No. 2; June 22, 2009.
- Medhi et al., “A Comparison of Mobile Money-Transfer UIs for Non-Literate and Semi-Literate Users,” Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, April 8, 2009.
- Owens et al., “Catching the Technology Wave: Mobile Phone Banking and Text-a-Payment in the Philippines,” 2006.Safaricom M-PESA Web Archive Snapshot; September 26, 2008.