Argon Plasma Coagulation System Probes, Their Components, and Other Argon Plasma Coagulation System Components for Use Therewith > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-1182
Filing Date Oct 7, 2019
Docket Number 3414
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Nov 8, 2019
Markman Hearing Start Date Jan 30, 2020
Markman Hearing End Date Jan 30, 2020
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Aug 31, 2020
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Sep 4, 2020
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date -
Target Date Mar 8, 2021
Final ID On Violation Due Date Nov 6, 2020
Final ID On Violation Issue Date -
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Aug 10, 2020
Final Determination of No Violation Aug 25, 2020
Final Determination of Violation -
Termination Date Aug 25, 2020
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Administrative JudgesCharles Bullock, Clark Cheney
Active JudgeClark Cheney
Respondent
9Complainant Attorneys
53Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Darren Donnelly
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Darren Donnelly
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Randal S. Alexander
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Randal S. Alexander
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Alexa Dicunzolo
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Alexa Dicunzolo
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Miya Yusa
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Miya Yusa
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Stephen J. Kraftschik
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen J. Kraftschik
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Shaleez E. Ozlat
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Shaleez E. Ozlat
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Enes Ovcina
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Enes Ovcina
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Latasha M. Snipes
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Latasha M. Snipes
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Rose Tamburi
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Rose Tamburi
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Christine Hotsko
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Christine Hotsko
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Isaac Horner
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Isaac Horner
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Greggory Holderman
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Greggory Holderman
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Merilee Johnson
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Merilee Johnson
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Daniel Macom
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Daniel Macom
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Robert Benimoff
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Benimoff
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Joshua L. Rayes
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshua L. Rayes
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Herbert F. Allen
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Herbert F. Allen
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: David L. Carr-Locke
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: David L. Carr-Locke
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Robert Tucker
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Tucker
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Krista F. Holt
Econ One Research, Inc.
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Krista F. Holt
Econ One Research, Inc.
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Jonathan D. Bonello
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Jonathan D. Bonello
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Alyssa M. Engstrom
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Alyssa M. Engstrom
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Aleece M. Hayes
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Aleece M. Hayes
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Sean M. Pluta
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Sean M. Pluta
Polsinelli
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Jeff Koishor
Veritext Legal Solutions
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeff Koishor
Veritext Legal Solutions
Erbe Elektromedizin GmbH
Attorney Name: Philip G. Hampton II
Polsinelli
Erbe USA Inc.
Attorney Name: Philip G. Hampton II
Polsinelli
Oly
Attorney Name: Philip G. Hampton II
Polsinelli
Respondent Attorneys
82Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Paul C. Goulet
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul C. Goulet
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Paul C. Goulet
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Katherine Kelly Vidal
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Katherine Kelly Vidal
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Katherine Kelly Vidal
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Steven M. Anzalone
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Steven M. Anzalone
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Steven M. Anzalone
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Daniel R. McNeely
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Daniel R. McNeely
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Daniel R. McNeely
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: David B. Houck
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: David B. Houck
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: David B. Houck
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Lawrence E. Slusky
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lawrence E. Slusky
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Lawrence E. Slusky
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Marjon Y. Momand
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Marjon Y. Momand
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Marjon Y. Momand
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Leah Romm
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Leah Romm
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Leah Romm
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Joann Losoya
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joann Losoya
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Joann Losoya
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Ned O'Brien
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ned O'Brien
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Ned O'Brien
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Heide Crossley
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Heide Crossley
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Heide Crossley
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Joshua Boria
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshua Boria
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Joshua Boria
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Eliza Spikes
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Eliza Spikes
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Eliza Spikes
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Nancy J. Martin
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Nancy J. Martin
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Nancy J. Martin
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Brian Mackey
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian Mackey
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Brian Mackey
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Ryan K. Black
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ryan K. Black
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Ryan K. Black
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Yarden Z. Kakon
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Yarden Z. Kakon
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Yarden Z. Kakon
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Dillon S. Kellerman
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Dillon S. Kellerman
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Dillon S. Kellerman
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Joo Ha Hwang
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joo Ha Hwang
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Joo Ha Hwang
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Siarra R. Rogers
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Siarra R. Rogers
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Siarra R. Rogers
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Jorge A. Ochoa
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jorge A. Ochoa
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Jorge A. Ochoa
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Judd Day
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Judd Day
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Judd Day
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Sangeeta Abraham
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sangeeta Abraham
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Sangeeta Abraham
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Philip Isenberg
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Philip Isenberg
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Philip Isenberg
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Shiva Khosharay
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Shiva Khosharay
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Shiva Khosharay
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Arielle Friedman
Winston & Strawn
Gyrus ACMI, Inc.
Attorney Name: Arielle Friedman
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Wi
Attorney Name: Arielle Friedman
Winston & Strawn
OLYMPUS WINTER & IBE GMBH
Attorney Name: Paul C. Goulet
Winston & Strawn
Attorney Name: E. Alexander Cruz
Winston & Strawn
OLYMPUS WINTER & IBE GMBH
Attorney Name: Katherine Kelly Vidal
Winston & Strawn
Olympus Corporation
Attorney Name: Joo Ha Hwang
Winston & Strawn
Related Patents
| Doc No | Title | Issue date |
|---|---|---|
| 09603653 | Apparatus for coagulating tissue | Mar 28, 2017 |
| 09510889 | Apparatus for coagulating tissue | Dec 6, 2016 |
| 07717911 | Instrument for plasma coagulation | May 18, 2010 |
| D0577671 | Connector | Sep 30, 2008 |
| 07311707 | Connecting device for an electrosurgical instrument | Dec 25, 2007 |
