Search
Patexia Research
Case number 337-TA-1226

Artificial Eyelash Extension Systems, Products, and Components Thereof > Summary

Court Case Number 337-TA-1226

Filing Date Sep 10, 2020

Docket Number 3488

Investigation Type Violation

Unfair Act Patent Infringement

Institution Date Oct 28, 2020

Markman Hearing Start Date Feb 17, 2021

Markman Hearing End Date Feb 17, 2021

Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Jul 12, 2021

Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Jul 15, 2021

Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date Jul 12, 2021

Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date Jul 12, 2021

Target Date Sep 12, 2022

Final ID On Violation Due Date Oct 28, 2021

Final ID On Violation Issue Date -

Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Oct 28, 2021

Final Determination of No Violation -

Final Determination of Violation Oct 6, 2022

Termination Date Oct 6, 2022

Court International Trade Commission

Status Terminated

Appeal2022-1566

Administrative JudgesCharles Bullock

Active JudgeCharles Bullock

Complainant

Complainant Attorneys

52

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jonathan T McMichael
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Patrick Ohryn Doyle
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Martyna Skrodzka
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric A. Menist
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Peiyao Zhang
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul M. Bartkowski
AMS Trade LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael R. Doman Jr.
AMS Trade LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas R. Burns
Bartkowski PLLC

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jae Woo Park
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Min Wu
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Vivian Baker
Vivian Baker

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert A. Iezzi
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Gwen Brass
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Timothy Cho
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas Ellis
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Tim Falk
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Patricia Frank
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sarah Goekler
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Veronica Guerrero
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Roosevelt Harrison
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Donna Kazaitis
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephanie Liu
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Marcia May
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Larry J. Moskowitz
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Carmen Murphy
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Barbara Nelson
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Curt Norris
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Valerie Rodriguez
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Deandrae M. Shivers
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jiwon Stanfield
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Cyril Suszkiewicz
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Una Wilkinson
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Shreyas A. Kale
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Vincent Thomas
Bartkowski PLLC

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Julie A. Nokleberg
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian M. Hoffman
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Emily Bullis
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kathryn M. Hauh
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Chris Huffman
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Derrick Sample
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Genevieve Barlow
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher J. Glancy
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric Majchrzak
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Shannon Turner
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: David Hadden
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Todd R. Gregorian
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jonathan Gordon Tamimi
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Bryan A. Kohm
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Melanie Mayer
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Su Li
Fenwick & West LLP

Lashify, Inc.
Attorney Name: Charles Moulins
Fenwick & West LLP

Respondent Attorneys

147

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Peter H. Kang
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Peter H. Kang
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Peter H. Kang
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Peter H. Kang
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Lisa M. Kattan
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lisa M. Kattan
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Lisa M. Kattan
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Lisa M. Kattan
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Lisa M. Kattan
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas C. Martin
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas C. Martin
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas C. Martin
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Thomas C. Martin
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Thomas C. Martin
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Welch
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Welch
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Welch
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Welch
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Welch
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric J. Faragi
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric J. Faragi
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric J. Faragi
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Eric J. Faragi
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Eric J. Faragi
Baker Botts LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Judy Wang
Steptoe LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher Jemin Hong
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Eliot D. Williams
Baker Botts LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Li Guo
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Matthew N. Bathon
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Hui Shen
Steptoe LLP

Lilac St.
Attorney Name: Hui Liu
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Wanat
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Wanat
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Wanat
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Robert Wanat
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Robert Wanat
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Peter H. Kang
Baker Botts LLP

Qingdao Hollyren Cosmetics Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: Peter H. Kang
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao Hollyren Cosmetics Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Ferenc Pazmandi
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ferenc Pazmandi
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Ferenc Pazmandi
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Ferenc Pazmandi
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Ferenc Pazmandi
Baker Botts LLP

Qingdao Hollyren Cosmetics Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jimmy Mays
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao Xizi International Trading Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jimmy Mays
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao Xizi International Trading Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Jimmy Mays
Steptoe LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Theodore W. Chandler
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Theodore W. Chandler
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Theodore W. Chandler
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Theodore W. Chandler
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Theodore W. Chandler
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Ann Park
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ann Park
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Ann Park
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Ann Park
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ann Park
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Sean S. Lee
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sean S. Lee
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Sean S. Lee
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Sean S. Lee
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Sean S. Lee
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher Palenik
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher Palenik
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher Palenik
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Christopher Palenik
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher Palenik
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas C. Martin
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Kassa
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Kassa
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Kassa
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Kassa
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Kassa
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshu Svenson
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshu Svenson
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshu Svenson
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Walmart
Attorney Name: Joshu Svenson
FTI Consulting, Inc.

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Joshu Svenson
FTI Consulting, Inc.

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Alan Ruffier
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Alan Ruffier
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Alan Ruffier
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Walmart
Attorney Name: Alan Ruffier
FTI Consulting, Inc.

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Alan Ruffier
FTI Consulting, Inc.

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: David Reeder
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: David Reeder
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: David Reeder
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Walmart
Attorney Name: David Reeder
FTI Consulting, Inc.

CVS Health
Attorney Name: David Reeder
FTI Consulting, Inc.

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Constantine Verenes
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Constantine Verenes
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Constantine Verenes
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Walmart
Attorney Name: Constantine Verenes
FTI Consulting, Inc.

CVS Health
Attorney Name: Constantine Verenes
FTI Consulting, Inc.

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Lee Boese
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lee Boese
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Lee Boese
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Lee Boese
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lee Boese
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Scott Duval
FTI Consulting, Inc.

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Scott Duval
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Scott Duval
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Scott Duval
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Walmart
Attorney Name: Scott Duval
FTI Consulting, Inc.

Artemis Family Beginnings Inc.
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Aaron Hawes
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Aaron Hawes
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Aaron Hawes
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Michael Aaron Hawes
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Aaron Hawes
Baker Botts LLP

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Lori Ding
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lori Ding
Baker Botts LLP

Cosmetics & Fragrance Inc.
Attorney Name: Lori Ding
Baker Botts LLP

Walmart
Attorney Name: Lori Ding
Baker Botts LLP

CVS Pharmacy, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lori Ding
Baker Botts LLP

Qingdao Hollyren Cosmetics Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew N. Bathon
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao Xizi International Trading Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew N. Bathon
Steptoe LLP

Artemis Family Beginnings Inc.
Attorney Name: Jason R. Bartlett
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP

Lilac St.
Attorney Name: Jason R. Bartlett
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Bill Toth
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Paul N. Birdsall
Steptoe LLP

Lilac St.
Attorney Name: Rory Jeffrey Radding
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP

Family Beginnings, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jason R. Bartlett
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP

Family Beginnings, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jason R. Bartlett
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: John M. Caracappa
Steptoe LLP

Lilac St.
Attorney Name: Rory Jeffrey Radding
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP

Qingdao Hollyren Cosmetics Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: Hui Shen
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao Xizi International Trading Co., Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew N. Bathon
Steptoe LLP

Qingdao LashBeauty Cosmetic Co.,Ltd
Attorney Name: Li Guo
Steptoe LLP

Attorney Name: Stanley M. Bryant
PARALEGAL

Lashify, Inc.

Lilac St.

Avant Garde Beauty Co.

KISS Products Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher Palenik
Baker Botts LLP

Ulta Beauty, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Baker Botts LLP

Related Patents

Doc No Title Issue date
10721984 Artificial lash extensions Jul 28, 2020
10660388 Artificial lash extensions May 26, 2020
D0877416 Storage cartridge for artificial eyelash extensions Mar 3, 2020
D0867664 Applicator for artificial lash extensions Nov 19, 2019
Menu