Automated Teller Machines, ATM Modules, Components Thereof and Products Containing Same > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-972
Filing Date Oct 19, 2015
Docket Number 3092
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Nov 20, 2015
Markman Hearing Start Date Apr 29, 2016
Markman Hearing End Date Apr 29, 2016
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Aug 29, 2016
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Sep 1, 2016
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date Aug 29, 2016
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date Sep 1, 2016
Target Date May 19, 2017
Final ID On Violation Due Date Nov 21, 2016
Final ID On Violation Issue Date Nov 30, 2016
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Nov 30, 2016
Final Determination of No Violation May 19, 2017
Final Determination of Violation -
Termination Date May 19, 2017
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Appeal2017-2563
Administrative JudgesSandra Lord
Active JudgeSandra Lord
Complainant
Complainant Attorneys
63Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: David S. Frist
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Max Rubinson
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Ana Kim
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Fannyben Dinubhai Patel
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Emily Chambers Welch
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Brandon M. White
Perkins Coie
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Kevin J. Patariu
Perkins Coie
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Shannon S. Campagna
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian D. Hill
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Lucia Lee
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Caitlin Heaton Smith
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Carolyn Correa
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: David Andre
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Pamela H. Councill
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: David Wettenstein
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Ann Park
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Leslie Todd
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Derek Fox
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Alex Jo
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeeyoung Hur
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Elvis Centano
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Elvis Centeno
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Lisa V. Feissner
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Mark McClure
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Michelle Anderson
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Goethals
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Susan D. Wasilewski
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas K. Feissner
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Trevor Price
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Mary Allred
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Mark Toomey
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Peter Yoon
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Hie-Chun Koh
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Nicole Villablanca
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Alex McDonald
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Ryan Herrington
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: William Singhose
Georgia Institute of Technology
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Mira Shin
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Francis Frederick
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Prowse
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Carl Jones
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Theodore B. Schroeder
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Scott J. Pivnick
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: James Austin Lee
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Hidetada James Abe
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Tennell Lockett
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher B. Kelly
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Leah Wood Feinman
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael H. Turner
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas R. Kurfess
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Sean B. Bedford
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Mary Ann Payonk
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Jamie D. Underwood
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Patrick J. Flinn
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Keith E. Broyles
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Jason P Cooper
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshua M. Weeks
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Attorney Name: Daniel J. O'Connor
Alston & Bird
Diebold Nixdorf Inc.
Alston & Bird
Diebold Self -
Attorney Name: Keith E. Broyles
Alston & Bird
Diebold Self -
Attorney Name: Patrick J. Flinn
Alston & Bird
Diebold Self -
Attorney Name: David S. Frist
Alston & Bird
Diebold Self -
Attorney Name: Joshua M. Weeks
Alston & Bird
Respondent Attorneys
142IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kevin C. Wheeler
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Michael J. McKeen
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael J. McKeen
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Timothy W. Riffe
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Timothy W. Riffe
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Michael A. Morin
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Margaret Upshaw
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Kyle S. Smith
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Alex M. Grabowski
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Amy Thomas
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Gabrielle Lahatte
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Dale Chang
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Gregory G. Garre
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Gabriel K. Bell
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Michael J. Gerardi
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Hyun Jin In
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Jared A. Smith
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Craig E. Countryman
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Jeff Sayres
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Phillip Kimball
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Wanda Robinson
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Robin Ferrill
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Ervin Farkas
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Nicholas A. Jepsen
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Humberto Ferrer
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Timothy Schelin
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Evan Newman
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Mary L. Uphold
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Renee Finkley
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Marlene Dori
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Richard M. Goodin
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Kyung-Sook Bai
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Wonmi Nam
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Sandra Rocca
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Anthony V. Nguyen
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Robert Courtney
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Rebecca Callow
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Sooyeon Lee
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: James Victory
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Robert L. Stevenson
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: William C. Messner
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Richard Hooper
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Charles Reinholtz
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Jacqueline Tio
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Linhong Zhang
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael A. Morin
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Margaret Upshaw
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kyle S. Smith
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Alex M. Grabowski
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Amy Thomas
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Gabrielle Lahatte
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Dale Chang
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Gregory G. Garre
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Gabriel K. Bell
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael J. Gerardi
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Craig E. Countryman
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ahmed J. Davis
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeff Sayres
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Phillip Kimball
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Wanda Robinson
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robin Ferrill
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ervin Farkas
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Nicholas A. Jepsen
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Humberto Ferrer
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Timothy Schelin
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Evan Newman
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Mary L. Uphold
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Renee Finkley
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Marlene Dori
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Richard M. Goodin
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kyung-Sook Bai
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Wonmi Nam
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sandra Rocca
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Anthony V. Nguyen
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Courtney
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Rebecca Callow
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sooyeon Lee
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: James Victory
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert L. Stevenson
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: William C. Messner
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Richard Hooper
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Charles Reinholtz
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jacqueline Tio
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Linhong Zhang
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Robert J. Gajarsa
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert J. Gajarsa
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Melissa Arbus Sherry
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Melissa Arbus Sherry
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Ron E. Shulman
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: David Slater
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: David Slater
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Bert C. Reiser
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Srinivas K. Giriraj Pathmanaban
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Srinivas K. Giriraj Pathmanaban
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Michael A. David
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael A. David
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Richard L. Bell
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Richard L. Bell
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Drew Wisniewski
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Drew Wisniewski
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Seung Wan (Andrew) Paik
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Seung Wan (Andrew) Paik
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Elana Nightingale Dawson
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Elana Nightingale Dawson
Latham & Watkins
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Ahmed J. Davis
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Will Orlady
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Will Orlady
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Thomas L. Halkowski
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas L. Halkowski
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Cherry Han
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Cherry Han
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Joseph V. Colaianni Jr.
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joseph V. Colaianni Jr.
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Michael C. Tyler
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael C. Tyler
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Zachary A. Loney
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Zachary A. Loney
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Patrick J. Bisenius
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Patrick J. Bisenius
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Binnie Martino
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Binnie Martino
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Robert S. Stevenson
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert S. Stevenson
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Jared M. Hartzman
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jared M. Hartzman
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Andrew Huh
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Andrew Huh
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: April Sunyoung Park
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: April Sunyoung Park
Fish & Richardson
Nautilus Hyosung America
Attorney Name: Thomas S. Fusco
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas S. Fusco
Fish & Richardson
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Daniel A. Tishman
Fish & Richardson
Attorney Name: Erika J. Weinstein
Latham & Watkins
IHS Global, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Jude McKeon
Fish & Richardson
continued ) Ace-Federal s, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Jude McKeon
Fish & Richardson
Related Patents
| Doc No | Title | Issue date |
|---|---|---|
| 07832631 | Method of reading coded records including magnetic indicia on checks deposited in an automated banking machine | Nov 16, 2010 |
| 07314163 | Check accepting and cash dispensing automated banking machine system and method | Jan 1, 2008 |
| 07249761 | ATM currency presenter gate arrangement | Jul 31, 2007 |
| 07229010 | Check accepting and cash dispensing automated banking machine system and method | Jun 12, 2007 |
| 07121461 | Reject bin having separated storage areas for diverted and retracted currency notes | Oct 17, 2006 |
| 06082616 | Automated banking machine enclosure | Jul 4, 2000 |
