Consumer Electronics, Including Mobile Phones and Tablets > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-839
Filing Date Mar 13, 2012
Docket Number 2885
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Apr 24, 2012
Markman Hearing Start Date -
Markman Hearing End Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Apr 30, 2013
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date May 10, 2013
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date -
Target Date Dec 2, 2013
Final ID On Violation Due Date Aug 2, 2013
Final ID On Violation Issue Date -
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Feb 4, 2013
Final Determination of No Violation Feb 22, 2013
Final Determination of Violation -
Termination Date Feb 21, 2013
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Administrative JudgesE. James Gildea, Edward Gildea
Active JudgeEdward Gildea
Complainant
Respondent
10Complainant Attorneys
22Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: William A. Marino
Marino & Grillo LLC
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Philip W. Marsh
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Anthony Grillo
Marino & Grillo LLC
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Dmitriy S. Andreyev
FlagshipIP
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Thomas T. Carmack
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: William Grillo
Marino & Grillo LLC
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: John A. Harre
Marino & Grillo LLC
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Albert Kim
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Sangmee Moon
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Hanna Moon
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Sean Grant
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Ramon Peraza
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Andrea Ignacio
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: William Henry Mangione-Smith
Marino & Grillo LLC
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Marc Levitt
Marino & Grillo LLC
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Robert P. Toczycki
FlagshipIP
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Aaron S. Buckler
FlagshipIP
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Michelle G. Breit
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Pragmatus AV LLC
Attorney Name: Anthony Gillo
Marino & Grillo LLC
Respondent Attorneys
128HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates
Google
Attorney Name: Michael J. Bettinger
K&L Gates
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Tawen Chang
Perkins Coie
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates
ASUS Computer International
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Jacob Oetama-Paul
Fish & Richardson
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
IMO INDUSTRIES
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Reed Smith
Attorney Name: Mark W. Wasserman
Reed Smith
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Cameron M. Nelson
Greenberg Traurig LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Cameron M. Nelson
Greenberg Traurig LLP
Pantech
Attorney Name: Cameron M. Nelson
Greenberg Traurig LLP
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Cameron M. Nelson
Greenberg Traurig LLP
Samsung LED America Inc.
Attorney Name: Cameron M. Nelson
Greenberg Traurig LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Cameron M. Nelson
Greenberg Traurig LLP
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Thomas S. Fusco
Fish & Richardson
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: James B. Coughlan
Perkins Coie
Fish & Richardson
Attorney Name: Thomas S. Fusco
Fish & Richardson
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Noah C. Graubart
Fish & Richardson
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Noah C. Graubart
Fish & Richardson
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Noah C. Graubart
Fish & Richardson
Pantech
Attorney Name: Noah C. Graubart
Fish & Richardson
IMO INDUSTRIES
Attorney Name: Noah C. Graubart
Fish & Richardson
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: John P. Schnurer
Perkins Coie
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Richard A. Edlin
Greenberg Traurig LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Richard D. Harris
Greenberg Traurig LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael J. Abernathy
K&L Gates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Younghye Kwon
HC Park & Associates
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Cheng (Jack) Ko
Perkins Coie
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael James Engle
Perkins Coie
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Kai Zhu
Perkins Coie
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.
Attorney Name: Yun L. Lu
Perkins Coie
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Hae-chan Park
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Thomas H. Ryou
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Jung-Ah Kim
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Nishat Hasan
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Vitter
K&L Gates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Vitter
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: James Olivier
K&L Gates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: James Olivier
K&L Gates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: James Olivier
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Gregory Leonard
K&L Gates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Gregory Leonard
K&L Gates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Gregory Leonard
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Cindy L. Sebo
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jason Levin
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Meghana Raorane
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Benjamin Hellerstein
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael S. Golenson
K&L Gates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Joshua B. Pond
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Joshua B. Pond
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Jackson R. Smith
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Jackson R. Smith
Fish & Richardson
Pantech
Attorney Name: Younghye Kwon
HC Park & Associates
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Amy L. Fulton
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Gregory K. Storey
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Hillary Cain Matheson
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Shaobin Zhu
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Thomas S. Fusco
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Jacob Oetama-Paul
Fish & Richardson
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Eric J. Maiers
Greenberg Traurig LLP
ASUS Computer International
Attorney Name: Tawen Chang
Perkins Coie
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Herbert H. Finn
Greenberg Traurig LLP
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Michael Swita
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
ASUS Computer International
Attorney Name: James B. Coughlan
Perkins Coie
ASUS Computer International
Attorney Name: Cheng (Jack) Ko
Perkins Coie
ASUS Computer International
Attorney Name: Michael James Engle
Perkins Coie
ASUS Computer International
Attorney Name: Kai Zhu
Perkins Coie
ASUS Computer International
Attorney Name: Yun L. Lu
Perkins Coie
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Justin A. Hendrix
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Douglas W. Meier
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
Pantech
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Hae-chan Park
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Thomas H. Ryou
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Jung-Ah Kim
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Nishat Hasan
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Joseph V. Colaianni Jr.
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Joseph V. Colaianni Jr.
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Erin P. Alper
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Christopher O. Green
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Christopher O. Green
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Benjamin Thompson
Fish & Richardson
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Rosa S. Jeong
Greenberg Traurig LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Barry R. Horwitz
Greenberg Traurig LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Elysa Q. Wan
Greenberg Traurig LLP
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Thomas Lewis Jarvis
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Michael J. McKeen
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Michael J. McKeen
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Noah C. Graubart
Fish & Richardson
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Vitter
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Dennis A. Majewski
K&L Gates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Oluwaseun Olugbolade Ajayi
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Oluwaseun Olugbolade Ajayi
HC Park & Associates
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: James K. Hammond
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Robert J. Barz
K&L Gates
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Matthew S. Dicke
K&L Gates
BlackBerry Ltd
Attorney Name: Samhitha Muralidhar Medatia
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Christy Vanessa La Pierre
K&L Gates
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Chang Joo Kim
Greenberg Traurig LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Wayne Helge
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Wayne Helge
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Stephen D. Dove
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Stephen D. Dove
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Kinari Patel
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Thomas Lewis Jarvis
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Heather Hall
Fish & Richardson
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Finnegan Henderson
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Howard Earl Silverman
Greenberg Traurig LLP
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Kenneth Clair
Fish & Richardson
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Perkins Coie
Pantech Wireless
Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: William A. Mason
HC Park & Associates
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC
Attorney Name: Michael J. Abernathy
K&L Gates
Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Michael Jude McKeon
Fish & Richardson
Related Patents
| Doc No | Title | Issue date |
|---|---|---|
| 07206809 | Method for real-time communication between plural users | Apr 17, 2007 |
| 07185054 | Participant display and selection in video conference calls | Feb 27, 2007 |
| 07054904 | Marking and searching capabilities in multimedia documents within multimedia collaboration networks | May 30, 2006 |
| 06237025 | Multimedia collaboration system | May 22, 2001 |
| 05854893 | System for teleconferencing in which collaboration types and participants by names or icons are selected by a participant of the teleconference | Dec 29, 1998 |
| 05854894 | Multi-media services system | Dec 29, 1998 |
