Electronic Devices and Semiconductor Devices with Timing-Aware Dummy Fill and Components Thereof (Violation) > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-1319
Filing Date Apr 28, 2022
Docket Number 3617
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Jun 13, 2022
Markman Hearing Start Date Oct 24, 2022
Markman Hearing End Date Oct 28, 2022
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date May 17, 2023
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date May 24, 2022
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date -
Target Date Feb 20, 2024
Final ID On Violation Due Date Oct 20, 2023
Final ID On Violation Issue Date Aug 1, 2022
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Aug 1, 2022
Final Determination of No Violation Aug 30, 2022
Final Determination of Violation -
Termination Date Aug 30, 2022
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Administrative JudgesMaryjoan McNamara
Active JudgeMaryjoan McNamara
Complainant
Respondent
22Complainant Attorneys
12Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Andrew F. Pratt
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Timothy Devlin
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Alex H. Chan
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Lowell D. Jacobson
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Andrew S. Brown
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Clifford Chad Henson
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: David Sochia
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Ashley N. Moore
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Richard A. Kamprath
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Bradley Jarrett
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Alexandra Easley
Devlin Law Firm
Bell Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Reginald David Lucas
United States International Trade Commission
Respondent Attorneys
209Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Brian Busey
Morrison & Foerster
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Rachel S. Dolphin
Morrison & Foerster
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Stefani E. Shanberg
Morrison & Foerster
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Jacob Baker
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Dean P. Neikirk
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Zijian Han
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Harper S. Batts
Sheppard Mullin
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Jeffrey A. Miller
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Jeffrey A. Miller
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeffrey A. Miller
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP
RoboSense
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Andrew N. Thomases
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Andrew N. Thomases
Ropes & Gray LLP
RoboSense
Attorney Name: Andrew N. Thomases
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Josef Bryks Schenker
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Josef Bryks Schenker
Ropes & Gray LLP
RoboSense
Attorney Name: Josef Bryks Schenker
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Brendan F. McLaughlin
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Brendan F. McLaughlin
Ropes & Gray LLP
RoboSense
Attorney Name: Brendan F. McLaughlin
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Alexis N. Ramsey
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Alexis N. Ramsey
Ropes & Gray LLP
RoboSense
Attorney Name: Alexis N. Ramsey
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Rebecca K. Gentilli
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Rebecca K. Gentilli
Ropes & Gray LLP
RoboSense
Attorney Name: Rebecca K. Gentilli
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: John N. Langa
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: John N. Langa
Ropes & Gray LLP
RoboSense
Attorney Name: John N. Langa
Ropes & Gray LLP
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP
NVidia
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Philip W. Marsh
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Philip W. Marsh
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Wolf
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Wolf
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Victoria Reines
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Victoria Reines
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Dina Marie Hayes
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Dina Marie Hayes
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Krysti Papadopoulos
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Krysti Papadopoulos
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Micron Technology, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jordan L. Coyle
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe
Micron Technology, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jared Bobrow
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe
Micron Technology, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeremy J. Lang
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe
Micron Technology, Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher P. Childers
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe
Micron Technology, Inc.
Attorney Name: Parth V. Sagdeo
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe
Micron Technology, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jasmine W. Zhu
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Harper S. Batts
Sheppard Mullin
Acer Incorporated
Attorney Name: Harper S. Batts
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Christopher S. Ponder
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Jeffrey Liang
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Edward B. Anderson
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Fred J. W. Chung
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Fangzhou Qiu
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Stephen Tang
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Zijian Han
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Ericka J. Schulz
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Ryan P. Cunningham
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Michael K. Heins
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: James Y. Hurt
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Matthew Duescher
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Jessica C. Hill
Covington & Burling LLP
Acer Incorporated
Attorney Name: Jessica C. Hill
Covington & Burling LLP
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Jessica C. Hill
Covington & Burling LLP
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: Jessica C. Hill
Covington & Burling LLP
Bose Corporation
Attorney Name: Jessica C. Hill
Covington & Burling LLP
Infineon Technologies AG
Attorney Name: Jessica C. Hill
Covington & Burling LLP
NVidia
Attorney Name: Mark D. Fowler
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Carrie L. Williamson
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Clayton Thompson
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Jake Zolotorev
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Marinna Chang Radloff
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Helena Drake Kiepura
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Joel C. Lin
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Erin M. McLaughlin
DLA Piper
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Mark D. Fowler
DLA Piper
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Mark D. Fowler
DLA Piper
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Carrie L. Williamson
DLA Piper
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Carrie L. Williamson
DLA Piper
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Alan A. Limbach
DLA Piper
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Alan A. Limbach
DLA Piper
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Marinna Chang Radloff
DLA Piper
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Marinna Chang Radloff
DLA Piper
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Helena Drake Kiepura
DLA Piper
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Helena Drake Kiepura
DLA Piper
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Erin M. McLaughlin
DLA Piper
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Erin M. McLaughlin
DLA Piper
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: Kevin K. Su
Fish & Richardson
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: Andrew G. Pearson
Fish & Richardson
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: David M. Barkan
Fish & Richardson
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: Leeron Kalay
Fish & Richardson
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: Olivia T. Nguyen
Fish & Richardson
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: Joshua Carrigan
Fish & Richardson
Bose Corporation
Attorney Name: Andrew R. Kopsidas
Hughes Hubbard & Reed
Bose Corporation
Attorney Name: Matthew Strobbe
Hughes Hubbard & Reed
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jessica C. Hill
Covington & Burling LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Tarek Austin
Covington & Burling LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher K. Eppich
Covington & Burling LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew B. Phelps
Covington & Burling LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Teena Sankoorikal
Covington & Burling LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: David A. Stanton
Covington & Burling LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Nitin Subhedar
Covington & Burling LLP
Infineon Technologies AG
Attorney Name: S. David Hoffman
Fish & Richardson
Infineon Technologies AG
Attorney Name: Jared A. Smith
Fish & Richardson
Infineon Technologies AG
Attorney Name: Daniel Wade
Fish & Richardson
Socionext America Inc.
Attorney Name: Mark L. Whitaker
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Mark L. Whitaker
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Max Olson
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext America Inc.
Attorney Name: Max Olson
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Akira Irie
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext America Inc.
Attorney Name: Akira Irie
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Takahiro Miura
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext America Inc.
Attorney Name: Takahiro Miura
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Mikaela L. Ediger
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext America Inc.
Attorney Name: Mikaela L. Ediger
Morrison & Foerster
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Blaney Harper
Jones Day
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Blaney Harper
Jones Day
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Blaney Harper
Jones Day
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Vishal V. Khatri
Jones Day
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Vishal V. Khatri
Jones Day
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Vishal V. Khatri
Jones Day
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Rita J. Yoon
Jones Day
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Rita J. Yoon
Jones Day
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Rita J. Yoon
Jones Day
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Steven J. Corr
Jones Day
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Steven J. Corr
Jones Day
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Steven J. Corr
Jones Day
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Yury Kalish
Jones Day
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Yury Kalish
Jones Day
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Yury Kalish
Jones Day
SMC Networks, Inc.
Attorney Name: Rich Vasquez
Vasquez Benisek & Lindgren
SMC Networks, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeffrey T. Lindgren
Vasquez Benisek & Lindgren
SMC Networks, Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric W. Benisek
Vasquez Benisek & Lindgren
SMC Networks, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert S. McArthur
Vasquez Benisek & Lindgren
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Deanna Okun
AMS Trade LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Daniel F. Smith
AMS Trade LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Juan J. Garcia
AMS Trade LLP
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sean Wesp
AMS Trade LLP
Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Max Olson
Morrison & Foerster
Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Takahiro Miura
Morrison & Foerster
Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Mikaela L. Ediger
Morrison & Foerster
LENOVO (BEIJING) CO., LTD.
Attorney Name: Stefani E. Shanberg
Morrison & Foerster
RoboSense
Attorney Name: Stefani E. Shanberg
Morrison & Foerster
LENOVO (BEIJING) CO., LTD.
Attorney Name: Robin L. Brewer
Morrison & Foerster
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Robin L. Brewer
Morrison & Foerster
LENOVO (BEIJING) CO., LTD.
Attorney Name: Karl Marshall Johnston
Morrison & Foerster
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Karl Marshall Johnston
Morrison & Foerster
LENOVO (BEIJING) CO., LTD.
Attorney Name: Veronica S. Ascarrunz
Morrison & Foerster
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Veronica S. Ascarrunz
Morrison & Foerster
LENOVO (BEIJING) CO., LTD.
Attorney Name: Aaron G. Fountain
Morrison & Foerster
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Aaron G. Fountain
Morrison & Foerster
LENOVO (BEIJING) CO., LTD.
Attorney Name: Hui Zhao
Morrison & Foerster
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Hui Zhao
Morrison & Foerster
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: David Nickel
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
NVidia
Attorney Name: Duane S. Boning
DLA Piper
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Ximena Solano Suarez
Sheppard Mullin
Acer Incorporated
Attorney Name: Ximena Solano Suarez
Sheppard Mullin
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Ximena Solano Suarez
Sheppard Mullin
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Jenna H. Spoont
Morrison & Foerster
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: John F. Presper
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Acer Incorporated
Attorney Name: John F. Presper
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: John F. Presper
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Acer Incorporated
Attorney Name: David Nickel
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: David Nickel
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Infineon Technologies AG
Attorney Name: Kevin K. Su
Fish & Richardson
Bose Corporation
Attorney Name: Kevin K. Su
Fish & Richardson
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Kevin K. Su
Fish & Richardson
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kevin K. Su
Fish & Richardson
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Francesco N. Mangini
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Francesco N. Mangini
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Francesco N. Mangini
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Analog Devices
Attorney Name: Majid Sarrafzadeh
Fish & Richardson
Kioxia Corporation
Attorney Name: Richard B. Fair
DLA Piper
KIOXIA AMERICA, INC.
Attorney Name: Richard B. Fair
DLA Piper
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Joel C. Lin
DLA Piper
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Daniel F. Smith
AMS Trade LLP
KIOXIKA Corporation
Attorney Name: Carrie L. Williamson
DLA Piper
KIOXIKA Corporation
Attorney Name: Erin M. McLaughlin
DLA Piper
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Dina Marie Hayes
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Victoria Reines
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Wolf
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Philip W. Marsh
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
NXP BV
Attorney Name: Krysti Papadopoulos
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael K. Heins
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Christopher S. Ponder
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Jeffrey Liang
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Fred J. W. Chung
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Ericka J. Schulz
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Fangzhou Qiu
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: James Y. Hurt
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Edward B. Anderson
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Stephen Tang
Sheppard Mullin
Acer America Corporation
Attorney Name: Ryan P. Cunningham
Sheppard Mullin
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Antonio Ramos
Morrison & Foerster
Socionext Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew Strobbe
Hughes Hubbard & Reed
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Svetlana Santos
Ropes & Gray LLP
KIOXIKA Corporation
Attorney Name: Alan A. Limbach
DLA Piper
NVidia
Attorney Name: Laurie E. Ouchida
DLA Piper
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Danute D. Abrishami
Covington & Burling LLP
NXP Semiconductors
Attorney Name: Andrea Solomon
Jones Day
Marvell Semiconductor
Attorney Name: Saron Harry
Ropes & Gray LLP
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Svetlana Santos
Ropes & Gray LLP
NXP USA, Inc.
Attorney Name: Andrea Solomon
Jones Day
NXP N.V.
Attorney Name: Andrea Solomon
Jones Day
Marvell Technology Group Ltd.
Attorney Name: Saron Harry
Ropes & Gray LLP
Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeffrey A. Miller
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer
Related Patents
Doc No | Title | Issue date |
---|---|---|
07007259 | Method for providing clock-net aware dummy metal using dummy regions | Feb 28, 2006 |