First Quality Tissue, LLC v. Irving Consumer Products Limited et al > Summary
Court Case Number 1:19-cv-00428
Filing Date Mar 1, 2019
Termination Date May 10, 2022
Court Delaware District Court
Status Judgment - Jury Verdict
Appeal2023-1784
JudgesRichard G. Andrews
Plaintiff
Defendant
Plaintiff Attorneys
27FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Edmond R. Bannon
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Nitika Gupta Fiorella
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Warren K. Mabey
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Ronald F. Vogel
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Casey M. Kraning
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Jeffrey C. Mok
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Joseph B. Warden
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Kelly A. Del Dotto
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Ethan J. Rubin
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Dale Kavalew
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Steven Keller
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Courtney Kessling
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Christopher A. Brown
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Dominick Glenn Vicari
Momentive Performance Materials Inc.
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Justin Pence
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Troy Runge
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: James Sealey
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Scott Crownover
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Byrd Tyler Miller, IV
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Benjamin Matthew Halpern
Amster Rothstein & Ebenstein
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Casey M. Kraning
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Edmond R. Bannon
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Ethan J. Rubin
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Jeffrey C. Mok
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Joseph B. Warden
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Kelly A. Del Dotto
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Edmond R. Bannon
Defendant Attorneys
36Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: John G. Day
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Andrew C. Mayo
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Marshall J. Schmitt
Michael Best & Friedrich
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Brianna J. Siebken
Michael Best & Friedrich
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jack B. Blumenfeld
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jeremiah A. Egger
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Inge A. Osman
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rebecca L. Rabenstein
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: David W. Rowe
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Charles H. Sanders
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rodger D. Smith II
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Paul A. Weinand
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Charles H. Sanders
Goodwin Procter LLP
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Scott M. Flanz
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Steve Bigford
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Philip Viger
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Dale Chang
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: David A. Zucker
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jeffrey G. Homrig
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jeremy T. Saks
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Mark LeBlanc
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: James E. Malackowski
Weil, Gotshal & Manges
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Alan Barc
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Ralph Forte
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Nathanial J. McPherson
Paul Weiss Rifkind Wharton & Garrison
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Shondra Jones
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Robert K. Irving
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Samuel Mitton
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Ida Lamanna
General Electric
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jack B. Blumenfeld
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Andrew C. Mayo
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jack B. Blumenfeld
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Andrew C. Mayo
Ashby & Geddes
Counter Defendant
7FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Edmond R. Bannon
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Nitika Gupta Fiorella
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Warren K. Mabey
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Warren K. Mabey
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Nitika Gupta Fiorella
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Warren K. Mabey
Fish & Richardson
FIRST QUALITY TISSUE, LLC
Attorney Name: Nitika Gupta Fiorella
Fish & Richardson
Counter Claimant
58Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: John G. Day
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Andrew C. Mayo
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Justin R. Cruz
Michael Best & Friedrich
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Marshall J. Schmitt
Michael Best & Friedrich
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Inge A. Osman
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rebecca L. Rabenstein
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: David W. Rowe
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Charles H. Sanders
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rodger D. Smith II
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Paul A. Weinand
Latham & Watkins
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Brianna J. Siebken
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Charles H. Sanders
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: David W. Rowe
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Inge A. Osman
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jeremiah A. Egger
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Justin R. Cruz
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Marshall J. Schmitt
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Nathanial J. McPherson
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Paul A. Weinand
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rebecca L. Rabenstein
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rodger D. Smith II
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: John G. Day
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Brianna J. Siebken
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Charles H. Sanders
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: David W. Rowe
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Inge A. Osman
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Jeremiah A. Egger
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Justin R. Cruz
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Marshall J. Schmitt
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Nathanial J. McPherson
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Paul A. Weinand
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rebecca L. Rabenstein
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rodger D. Smith II
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: John G. Day
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Charles H. Sanders
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: David W. Rowe
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Inge A. Osman
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Paul A. Weinand
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rebecca L. Rabenstein
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rodger D. Smith II
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: John G. Day
Ashby & Geddes
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Charles H. Sanders
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: David W. Rowe
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Inge A. Osman
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Moore
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Maximilian A. Grant
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Paul A. Weinand
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rebecca L. Rabenstein
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: Rodger D. Smith II
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell
Irving Consumer Products
Attorney Name: John G. Day
Ashby & Geddes
Cause
35:1 Patent Infringement
Related Patents
| Doc No | Title | Issue date |
|---|---|---|
| 09725853 | Soft through air dried tissue | Aug 8, 2017 |
| 09580872 | Soft through air dried tissue | Feb 28, 2017 |
| 09506203 | Soft through air dried tissue | Nov 29, 2016 |
| 09508872 | Method for manufacturing semiconductor device and pin diode | Nov 29, 2016 |
