IP Camera Systems including Video Doorbells and Components Thereof > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-1242
Filing Date Dec 18, 2020
Docket Number 3517
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Jan 28, 2021
Markman Hearing Start Date Jun 16, 2021
Markman Hearing End Date Jun 16, 2021
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Nov 3, 2021
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Nov 9, 2021
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date -
Target Date May 27, 2022
Final ID On Violation Due Date Jan 27, 2022
Final ID On Violation Issue Date -
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Sep 15, 2021
Final Determination of No Violation -
Final Determination of Violation Nov 10, 2021
Termination Date Nov 10, 2021
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Appeal2022-1354
Administrative JudgesSandra Lord, Clark Cheney
Active JudgeClark Cheney
Complainant Attorneys
46SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Rett Snotherly
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Rett Snotherly
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Gary R. Sorden
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Gary R. Sorden
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Gary R. Sorden
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Aaron D. Davidson
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Aaron D. Davidson
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Aaron D. Davidson
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Vishal H. Patel
Cole Schotz
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Vishal H. Patel
Cole Schotz
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Vishal H. Patel
Cole Schotz
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Niky R. Bagley
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Niky R. Bagley
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Niky R. Bagley
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Timothy J. Craddock
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Timothy J. Craddock
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Timothy J. Craddock
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: James Robert Perkins
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: James Robert Perkins
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: James Robert Perkins
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian L. King
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Brian L. King
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Brian L. King
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Akl
Cole Schotz
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Tidwell
Cole Schotz
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Cole Schotz
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Randal H. Direen
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Randal H. Direen
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Randal H. Direen
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robb Helt
DeFacto Trialworks
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Robb Helt
DeFacto Trialworks
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Robb Helt
DeFacto Trialworks
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jason Bencze
DeFacto Trialworks
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Jason Bencze
DeFacto Trialworks
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Jason Bencze
DeFacto Trialworks
SkyBell Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Hoda Rifai-Bashjawish
Cole Schotz
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Hoda Rifai-Bashjawish
Cole Schotz
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Hoda Rifai-Bashjawish
Cole Schotz
Technology Holdings
Attorney Name: Gary R. Sorden
Cole Schotz
Technology Holdings
Attorney Name: Brian L. King
Cole Schotz
Eyetalk365, LLC
Attorney Name: Robert Akl
Cole Schotz
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Robert Tidwell
Cole Schotz
Respondent Attorneys
66Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Eric S. Namrow
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sean Cunningham
DLA Piper
Vivint
Attorney Name: David R. Wright
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Kirk R. Harris
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Michael A. Manookin
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Trevor Lawrence Clark
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Christina Le Trinh
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Daniel E. Yonan
Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox
Vivint
Attorney Name: Dallin G. Glenn
Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshua M. Dalton
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jason E. Gettleman
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Julie S. Goldemberg
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Hersh H. Mehta
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephanie L. Roberts
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Riccardo Macchiaroli
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Calvin M. Brien
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Austin L. Zuck
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Candace M. Polster
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Erin P. Gibson
DLA Piper
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Williams
DLA Piper
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: David R. Knudson
DLA Piper
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Catherine K. Huang
DLA Piper
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Adam R. Alper
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Akshay S. Deoras
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Maria M. Beltran
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Leslie M. Schmidt
Kirkland & Ellis
Vivint
Attorney Name: Davin Guinn
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael W. De Vries
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Mark D. Fahey
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Irene Jang
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Gavin W. Moler
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas F. Nowland
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas Y. Nolan
Morgan Lewis & Bockius
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Zoya Kovalenko
Kirkland & Ellis
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Esam Sharafuddin
DLA Piper
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeffrey R. Cole
DLA Piper
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kristina R. Cary
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Wesley Wozniak
Fulcrum Legal Graphics
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Charles J. Hickey III
Fulcrum Legal Graphics
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Peter Holwitz
Fulcrum Legal Graphics
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Steven Bolinger
Fulcrum Legal Graphics
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sofia Stephens
Fulcrum Legal Graphics
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Peter F. Nelson
DLA Piper
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Victoria Huang
Kirkland & Ellis
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Laura Zhu
Kirkland & Ellis
Vivint
Attorney Name: Robert L. Stoll
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Kenneth P. Wacks
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: John D. Villasenor
DLA Piper
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kevin C. Almeroth
Kirkland & Ellis
Arlo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Julia Rowe
Duff & Phelps
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Julia Rowe
Duff & Phelps
Vivint
Attorney Name: Julia Rowe
Duff & Phelps
Attorney Name: Frank Carlow
Kirkland & Ellis
Vivint
Attorney Name: Charles S. Barquist
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Daniel E. Yonan
Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox
Vivint
Attorney Name: Dallin G. Glenn
Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox
Vivint
Attorney Name: Kirk R. Harris
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Trevor Lawrence Clark
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: David R. Wright
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Michael A. Manookin
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Christina Le Trinh
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
SB IP Holdings LLC
Attorney Name: Robb Helt
Cole Schotz
Simplisafe, Inc.
Attorney Name: Wesley Wozniak
Kirkland & Ellis
Vivint
Attorney Name: Robert L. Stoll
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Vivint
Attorney Name: Kenneth P. Wacks
Maschoff Brennan Gilmore Israelsen & Mauriel LLP
Related Patents
| Doc No | Title | Issue date |
|---|---|---|
| 10674120 | Communication and monitoring system | Jun 2, 2020 |
| 10523906 | Communication and monitoring system | Dec 31, 2019 |
| 10200660 | Communication and monitoring system | Feb 5, 2019 |
| 10097796 | Communication and monitoring system | Oct 9, 2018 |
| 10097797 | Communication and monitoring system | Oct 9, 2018 |
| 09485478 | Communication and monitoring system | Nov 1, 2016 |
| 09432638 | Communication and monitoring system | Aug 30, 2016 |
