Integrated Circuit Devices and Products Containing the Same > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-873
Filing Date Feb 8, 2013
Docket Number 2938
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Mar 15, 2013
Markman Hearing Start Date -
Markman Hearing End Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Feb 24, 2014
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Mar 7, 2014
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date Feb 24, 2014
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date Mar 7, 2014
Target Date Dec 1, 2014
Final ID On Violation Due Date Aug 1, 2014
Final ID On Violation Issue Date -
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Aug 1, 2014
Final Determination of No Violation Aug 27, 2014
Final Determination of Violation -
Termination Date Aug 27, 2014
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Administrative JudgesEdward Gildea, Robert Rogers
Active JudgeEdward Gildea
Complainant
Respondent
7Complainant Attorneys
54Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Yue Li
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Charles F. Koch
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Tuhin Ganguly
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: David P. Shaw
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tele Innovations Inc.
Attorney Name: Goutam Patnaik
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Andy H. Chan
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Akim Graham
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Alex Miller
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: James F. Doyle
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Katie Kulow
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michele Eddy
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Griffin N. Mesmer
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Nancy Mahoney
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Holly Thuman
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Erja Vettenranta
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Margaret A. Bachner
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ronald L. Cook
Merrill Corp Ltd
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Steve Hubbard
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sherri Starr
Merrill Corp Ltd
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sue Terry
Merrill Corp Ltd
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kevin B. Sullivan
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sohyon Kim
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Li
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jean Yi
Accesslink, LLC
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lance Glasser
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kathryn Kobe
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Manish Bhardwaj
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sumeet Maini
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: David A. Ward
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Paula Stern
The Stern Group
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ezekial Kruglick
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael H. Durbin
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lauren E. Reznick
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Melissa H. Davis
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kelly E. Rose
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Goutam Patnaik
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: William D. Belanger
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas Fitzpatrick
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jaclyn M. Essinger
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: David J. Shaw
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: David Michael Magee
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Frank D. Liu
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Alison L. McCarthy
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Daniel Stone
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Gregory D. Len
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: George S. Haight
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Tela Innovations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Pepper Hamilton
Goutam Patnaik
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP
Respondent Attorneys
178Nokia
Attorney Name: Seth R. Smith
Cooley LLP
Motorola Solutions, Inc.
Attorney Name: Seth R. Smith
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
Pantech
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Nokia
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: James Victory
HC Park & Associates
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Sanjay Banerjee
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Gregory Leonard
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Vivek Subramanian
Steptoe LLP
Pantech
Attorney Name: Jacqueline M. Lee
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Sok K. Hong
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Hae-chan Park
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Wayne Helge
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Thomas H. Ryou
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Nishat Hasan
HC Park & Associates
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Michael Rhodes
Cooley LLP
Motorola Solutions, Inc.
Attorney Name: Roy Campus
Cooley LLP
Motorola Solutions, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jon Owens
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Rose Sivana Whelan
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: John Harmonson
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Jordan Mummart
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Krishna Sharma
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Jill Kustner
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Zachary Ryanland
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Jeffrey Reynolds
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Piyatida Shiozaki
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Scott Hilton
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Aaron Stienstra
The Focal Point LLC
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Yousif Abdelaziz
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Mike McLean
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: James Victory
HC Park & Associates
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Zack Wojcik
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Susan Magee
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Aric Kerhulas
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Cynthia Manning
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Sean McGrath
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Jacqueline M. Lee
HC Park & Associates
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Mark R. Schafer
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Sok K. Hong
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Hae-chan Park
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Wayne Helge
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Thomas H. Ryou
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Nishat Hasan
HC Park & Associates
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Eamonn J. Gardner
Cooley LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Seth R. Smith
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Roy Campus
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jon Owens
Cooley LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
Motorola Solutions, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
MTTO LLC
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Rose Sivana Whelan
Cooley LLP
Nokia
Attorney Name: Taryn Williams
King & Spalding
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Erin Carey Trenda
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Erin Carey Trenda
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: John Harmonson
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jordan Mummart
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Mary Ann Payonk
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Mary Ann Payonk
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Krishna Sharma
Cooley LLP
Nokia
Attorney Name: Lori Goodin
King & Spalding
Nokia
Attorney Name: Jason Levin
King & Spalding
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jill Kustner
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Zachary Ryanland
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jeffrey Reynolds
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Piyatida Shiozaki
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Nicolas J. Echevestre
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Nicolas J. Echevestre
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Scott Hilton
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Aaron Stienstra
The Focal Point LLC
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Yousif Abdelaziz
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Seth R. Smith
Cooley LLP
Nokia
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Danielle Grant
Steptoe LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Orion Armon
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Brian Lam
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Mike McLean
Cooley LLP
Pantech
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Nokia
Attorney Name: Vincent Thomas
King & Spalding
Nokia
Attorney Name: Jack C. Lee
King & Spalding
Nokia
Attorney Name: Bruce Smith
King & Spalding
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Zack Wojcik
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Susan Magee
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Aric Kerhulas
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Cynthia Manning
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Sean McGrath
Cooley LLP
Nokia
Attorney Name: Christian M. Dippon
NERA Economic Consulting
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Thomas M. Croft
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Thomas M. Croft
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Gu-Yeon Wei
Harvard University
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Tsu-Jae King Lui
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Alan A. Wright
HC Park & Associates
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Seth R. Smith
Cooley LLP
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: Aaron R. Fahrenkrog
Robins Kaplan LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Mark R. Schafer
Cooley LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Harry Hyunho Park
Steptoe LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Steven Strauss
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Steven Strauss
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Timothy S. Teter
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Timothy S. Teter
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Benjamin G. Damstedt
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Benjamin G. Damstedt
Cooley LLP
Pantech
Attorney Name: Stephen D. Dove
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Stephen D. Dove
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Younghye Kwon
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Younghye Kwon
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Oluwaseun Olugbolade Ajayi
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Oluwaseun Olugbolade Ajayi
HC Park & Associates
Pantech
Attorney Name: Brendan Padraig O'Shea
HC Park & Associates
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Brendan Padraig O'Shea
HC Park & Associates
Nokia
Attorney Name: Allison H. Altersohn
King & Spalding
Nokia
Attorney Name: Christopher C. Carnaval
King & Spalding
Nokia
Attorney Name: Robert Francis Perry
King & Spalding
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Karr
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Karr
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Eamonn J. Gardner
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Kyle D. Chen, Ph.D.
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Lia Smith
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Joseph M. Drayton
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Mark R. Weinstein
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Brian Patrick Wikner
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Brigham
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Brigham
Cooley LLP
HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Laura Cunningham
Cooley LLP
Motorola Mobility LLC
Attorney Name: Laura Cunningham
Cooley LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Taras A. Gracey
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Robert Gary Pluta
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Brandon C. Helms
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Amanda Streff Bonner
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Charles Frederick Schill
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Kfir B. Levy
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Michael Maas
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Tiffany A. Miller
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Baldine B. Paul
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics
Attorney Name: Alison M. Gelsleichter
Steptoe LLP
Nokia
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Seddon II
King & Spalding
Nokia
Attorney Name: Carol Brewer
King & Spalding
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Jamie B. Beaber
Steptoe LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Steven Strauss
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Joseph M. Drayton
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Karr
Cooley LLP
Nokia
Attorney Name: Laura Williams
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Timothy S. Teter
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Michael Rhodes
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Brigham
Cooley LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Gary Pluta
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Alison M. Gelsleichter
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Baldine B. Paul
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Maas
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Kfir B. Levy
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Harry Hyunho Park
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Taras A. Gracey
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Brandon C. Helms
Steptoe LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Charles Frederick Schill
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Tiffany A. Miller
Steptoe LLP
LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.
Attorney Name: Amanda Streff Bonner
Steptoe LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Christopher C. Carnaval
King & Spalding
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Taryn Williams
King & Spalding
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Jeffrey S. Seddon II
King & Spalding
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Allison H. Altersohn
King & Spalding
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Robert Francis Perry
King & Spalding
Pantech
Attorney Name: Kenneth Clair
Thomson West
PANTECH C0.. LTD.
Attorney Name: Angela Ruby
LEXISNEXIS RISK SOLUTIONS INC.
Pantech
Attorney Name: Lori Hofer
LEXISNEXIS RISK SOLUTIONS INC.
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Young Sun Kwon
HC Park & Associates
Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Timothy S. Teter
Cooley LLP
Pantech Wireless
Attorney Name: Anthony Gene Beasley
Robins Kaplan LLP
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc
Attorney Name: William H. Manning
Robins Kaplan LLP
