Patexia Research

Case number IPR2014-01385

Lawsuits

International Business Machines Corporation v. Intellectual Ventures I LLC > Summary

Court Case Number IPR2014-01385

Filing Date Aug 26, 2014

Institution Decision Date Feb 11, 2015

Decision Date Jan 15, 2016

Court Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Status Final Written Decision

Appeal2016-1938

Administrative JudgesBarbara A. Parvis, Jennifer S. Bisk, Joni Y. Chang

Judge Writing the Final DecisionBarbara A. Parvis

Claims Challenged in the Petition: 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 11, 12, 13, 21, 22, 23, 24

Claims Instituted: 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 11, 12, 13, 21, 22, 23, 24

Claims Invalidated: 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 11, 12, 13, 21, 22, 23, 24

Petitioner

International Business Machines

Patent Owner

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

Petitioner Attorneys

8

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Brent P. Ray
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Kenneth R. Adamo
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Eugene Goryunov
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Joel R. Merkin
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: David W. Higer
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Ian Neville Feinberg
Kramer Alberti Lim & Tonkovich LLP

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: William Irvin Dunnegan
Dunnegan & Scileppi LLC

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Richard Reader
Oracle Corporation

Patent Owner Attorneys

13

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Tim R. Seeley
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Donald J. Coulman
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Bridget A. Smith
Knobbe Martens

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: David G. Jankowski
Knobbe Martens

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Ted M. Cannon
Knobbe Martens

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Brenton R. Babcock
Knobbe Martens

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Ted M. Cannon
Knobbe Martens

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Tim R. Seeley
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Donald J. Coulman
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Bridget A. Smith
Knobbe Martens

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: David G. Jankowski
Knobbe Martens

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Brenton R. Babcock
Knobbe Martens

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Michael E. McCabe, Jr
FUNK & BOLTON, P.A.

Related Patents

Doc No	Title	Issue date
07984081	System and method for non-programmers to dynamically manage multiple sets of XML document data	Jul 19, 2011