Search
Patexia Research
Case number 337-TA-1138

LTE- and 3G-Compliant Cellular Communications Devices > Summary

Court Case Number 337-TA-1138

Filing Date Sep 14, 2018

Docket Number 3342

Investigation Type Violation

Unfair Act Patent Infringement

Institution Date Oct 19, 2018

Markman Hearing Start Date Apr 3, 2019

Markman Hearing End Date Apr 3, 2019

Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Sep 12, 2019

Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Sep 23, 2019

Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date Sep 12, 2019

Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date Sep 23, 2019

Target Date Jun 15, 2020

Final ID On Violation Due Date Feb 18, 2020

Final ID On Violation Issue Date Feb 18, 2020

Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Feb 18, 2020

Final Determination of No Violation -

Final Determination of Violation Jun 1, 2020

Termination Date Jun 1, 2020

Court International Trade Commission

Status Terminated

Appeal2020-1903

Administrative JudgesMaryjoan McNamara

Active JudgeMaryjoan McNamara

Complainant

Complainant Attorneys

89

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Carlos Rodas
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Margaret Anthony
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Ari Bonnett
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Dianna Case
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jordan Ray
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: John Ilg
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Adam Wirtzfeld
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Denise D. Vickery
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Ioannis Arsenis
Robins Kaplan LLP

Fortress Investment Group LLC
Attorney Name: Christopher Seidl
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Kevin Marth
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Patricia Carl
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Silvia Wage
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Henry Marte
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Daniel Holmstock
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jonathan Babb
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: William Henry Mangione-Smith
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Ray W. Nettleton
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Branimir R. Vojcic
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Derrick J. Carman
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: John K. Harting
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Benjamen C. Linden
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Shui Li
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Li Zhu
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: William Earl Manske
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Cyrus A. Morton
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Mary Pheng
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Dov Hirsch
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Stephanie A. Diehl
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Annie Huang
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Taylor Moore-Willis
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Christopher Seidl
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Christine S. Yun Sauer
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Kristyn Berretta
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Richard Brady
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jennifer Hulst
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Sanjana Shah
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Ryan Sullivan
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Brandi Bigalk
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jason Sayler
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Debby Campeau
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Will Rain
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Rebecca Graziano
Robins Kaplan LLP

Samsung Electronics
Attorney Name: Larry Lee Shatzer
Strain PLLC

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Yu Chen
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Brandi Bigalke
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Victoria Valine
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Albert Maimon
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Chester Wong
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Connie Recob
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Naomi Collado
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Pat Carl
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jade King
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Chun Un
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Gabe Martin
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Luke Hsieh
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Tracy Jones
INVT SPE LLC

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Patty Guerrero
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Doug Weimerskirch
Robins Kaplan LLP

Samsung Austin Semiconductor, LLC
Attorney Name: Larry Lee Shatzer
Strain PLLC

Samsung Research America
Attorney Name: Larry Lee Shatzer
Strain PLLC

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Joshua W. Lathrop
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Sarita Bhattacharya
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Amy Olitsky
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Colette Porter
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Caroline Iannacone
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Ryan Deloughry
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Michael A. Cicchino
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Laurence Rosenberg
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Deepa Sundararaman
Robins Kaplan LLP

Branimir Vojcic
Attorney Name: Branimir R. Vojcic
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Gregory Sidak
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Michael Q. Hubbard
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Timothy Patrick Hughes
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Aimee L. Page
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Larry Lee Shatzer
Strain PLLC

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Bryan J. Vogel
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jefrey A. Lamken
MoloLamken LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Lucas M. Walker
MoloLamken LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Sara E. Margolis
MoloLamken LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Benjamin T. Sirolly
MoloLamken LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Rayiner Hashem
MoloLamken LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jennifer E. Fischell
MoloLamken LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Jefrey A. Lamken
MoloLamken LLP

United States International Trade Commission

Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Branimir R. Vojcic
Robins Kaplan LLP

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Ray W. Nettleton
Ray Nettleton

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Daniel Holmstock
Robins Kaplan LLP

Respondent Attorneys

182

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert A. Appleby
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Robert A. Appleby
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Robert A. Appleby
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Ericka J. Schulz
Sheppard Mullin

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: David Rokach
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Leslie M. Schmidt
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Leslie M. Schmidt
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Leslie M. Schmidt
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Brian A. Jones
McDermott Will & Emery

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul F. Brinkman
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Paul F. Brinkman
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Paul F. Brinkman
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Stephen Sandor Korniczky
Sheppard Mullin

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Jay H. Reiziss
McDermott Will & Emery

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Wei (Vivan) Josh
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Martin R. Bader
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Edward B. Anderson
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Ryan P. Cunningham
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Eric K. Gill
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Emilio A. Cazares
Sheppard Mullin

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Sandor Korniczky
Sheppard Mullin

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Stephen Sandor Korniczky
Sheppard Mullin

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Wesley Wozniak
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael Lake
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Peter Holwitz
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew Nolte
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeff Sayres
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Charles J. Hickey III
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Helena Drake Kiepura
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Carmen Smith
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Jay H. Reiziss
McDermott Will & Emery

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jay H. Reiziss
McDermott Will & Emery

United States International Trade Commission
Attorney Name: Paul F. Brinkman
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: David Rokach
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: David Rokach
Kirkland & Ellis

Kirkland & Ellis
Attorney Name: Robert A. Appleby
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Edward A. Infante
Jams

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Susan Ashe
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Susan Ashe
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Susan Ashe
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Martin Sherrill
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Martin Sherrill
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Martin Sherrill
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Jessica Waack
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jessica Waack
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Jessica Waack
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Wicker
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Stephen Wicker
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Stephen Wicker
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Prowse
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Stephen Prowse
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Stephen Prowse
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Ryan Herrington
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Ryan Herrington
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Ryan Herrington
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Emily Etnyre
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Emily Etnyre
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Emily Etnyre
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Rachel Leos
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Rachel Leos
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Rachel Leos
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Kenny Lamb
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Kenny Lamb
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Kenny Lamb
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Bonnie Harvey
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Bonnie Harvey
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Bonnie Harvey
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Evan Berkowitz
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Evan Berkowitz
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Evan Berkowitz
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Brandon Forsythe
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Brandon Forsythe
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Brandon Forsythe
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Howard Klein
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Howard Klein
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Howard Klein
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Anthony S. Acampora
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Anthony S. Acampora
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Anthony S. Acampora
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Benjamin F. Goldberg
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Benjamin F. Goldberg
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Benjamin F. Goldberg
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Arielle Santos
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Arielle Santos
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Arielle Santos
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Juan Torres
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Juan Torres
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Juan Torres
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Charles M. McMahon
McDermott Will & Emery

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeff Eisenach
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Kulick
NERA Economic Consulting

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: John Laurini
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Patrick McGervey
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Janusz R. Mrozek
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Megan Ye
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Danielle Vazquez
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Hector Lopez
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Nicole Lin
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Sergio Garcia
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew Ginsberg
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul Meyer
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian Badala
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Bruce Service
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Jacob Weniz
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Max Roberts
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: William Leitsch
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Karen Cator
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Susan Thomas
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Katie Ochetal
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Katie Ochetal
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Katie Ochetal
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Lynne M. Ledanois
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Lynne M. Ledanois
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Lynne M. Ledanois
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Reynaldo Adesamis
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Reynaldo Adesamis
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Reynaldo Adesamis
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Linda Vaccarezza
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Linda Vaccarezza
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Linda Vaccarezza
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Erik Parker
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Erik Parker
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Erik Parker
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Alexander P. Ott
McDermott Will & Emery

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Thomas M. Damario Jr.
McDermott Will & Emery

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael J. Hopkins
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Nam H. Kim
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Hsiuyu Wang
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Tricia (Hsiao-Wen) Lee
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Mario H. Lopez
Sheppard Mullin

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Rebecca Callow
McDermott Will & Emery

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Kathleen Wilkins
McDermott Will & Emery

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Amanda Lin
McDermott Will & Emery

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: John Wissenbach
McDermott Will & Emery

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Sean McGrath
McDermott Will & Emery

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Philippe Stoffel-Munck
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Philippe Stoffel-Munck
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Amol A. Parikh
McDermott Will & Emery

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Matthew M. Girgenti
McDermott Will & Emery

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Apostolos K. Kakaes
Cosmos Communications Consulting

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Apostolos K. Kakaes
Cosmos Communications Consulting

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Apostolos K. Kakaes
Cosmos Communications Consulting

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Jesse Hindman
Hindman APC

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Jesse Hindman
Hindman APC

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Hannah Lynn Cannom
Walker Stevens Cannom LLP

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Wicker
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Stephen Wicker
Kirkland & Ellis

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Stephen Wicker
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Benjamin Yaghoubian
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Ximena Solano Suarez
Sheppard Mullin

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Carrie A. Ross
Sheppard Mullin

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Jiaxiao Zhang
McDermott Will & Emery

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeanne M. Heffernan
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Akshay S. Deoras
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Alan M. Rabinowitz
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Rajat Khanna
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian H. Gold
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: John R. Rhine
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Karthik Ravishankar
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Alex Shank
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Lida Ramsey
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Nathan S. Mammen
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: John C. O'Quinn
Kirkland & Ellis

United States International Trade Commission

ZTE USA
Attorney Name: Jay H. Reiziss
McDermott Will & Emery

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Stephen Sandor Korniczky
Sheppard Mullin

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Charles J. Hickey III
Kirkland & Ellis

Apple Inc.

Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Donn Waslif
Morgan Franich Fredkin Siamas & Kays

United States International Trade Commission

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Philippe Stoffel-Munck
Kirkland & Ellis

HTC Corporation
Attorney Name: Stephen Sandor Korniczky
Sheppard Mullin

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Wicker
Kirkland & Ellis

Intel Corporation
Attorney Name: Brandon Forsythe
Kirkland & Ellis

Intel Corporation
Attorney Name: Howard Klein
Kirkland & Ellis

Samsung Research America
Attorney Name: Paul D. Strain
Strain PLLC

Samsung Research America
Attorney Name: Stephen G. Nagy
Strain PLLC

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Gregory S. Arovas
Kirkland & Ellis

INVT SPE LLC
Attorney Name: Patricia Guererro
Robins Kaplan LLP

Apple Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Kulick
Kirkland & Ellis

Menu