Search
Patexia Research
Case number 337-TA-909

Non-Volatile Memory Devices and Products Containing Same > Summary

Court Case Number 337-TA-909

Filing Date Dec 27, 2013

Docket Number 2996

Investigation Type Violation

Unfair Act Patent Infringement

Institution Date Feb 3, 2014

Markman Hearing Start Date -

Markman Hearing End Date -

Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Oct 21, 2014

Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Oct 27, 2014

Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date Oct 21, 2014

Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date Oct 27, 2014

Target Date Jun 3, 2015

Final ID On Violation Due Date Feb 3, 2015

Final ID On Violation Issue Date -

Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Jan 30, 2015

Final Determination of No Violation Mar 2, 2015

Final Determination of Violation -

Termination Date Mar 4, 2015

Court International Trade Commission

Status Terminated

Administrative JudgesDavid P. Shaw

Active JudgeDavid P. Shaw

Respondent Attorneys

240

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Beats Electronics, LLC
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs Operations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs North America Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Rebecca R. Hermes
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Rebecca R. Hermes
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Rebecca R. Hermes
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Rebecca R. Hermes
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs Operations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Rebecca R. Hermes
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs North America Inc.
Attorney Name: Rebecca R. Hermes
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Darrell W. Stark
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Darrell W. Stark
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Darrell W. Stark
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Darrell W. Stark
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs Operations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Darrell W. Stark
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs North America Inc.
Attorney Name: Darrell W. Stark
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Caroline L. Greenwood
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Caroline L. Greenwood
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Caroline L. Greenwood
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Caroline L. Greenwood
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs Operations, Inc.
Attorney Name: Caroline L. Greenwood
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs North America Inc.
Attorney Name: Caroline L. Greenwood
Ropes & Gray LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Michael L. Doane
AMS Trade LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Steven M. Balcof
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Steven M. Balcof
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Steven M. Balcof
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Steven M. Balcof
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs
Attorney Name: Steven M. Balcof
Ropes & Gray LLP

Ruckus Networks
Attorney Name: Steven M. Balcof
Ropes & Gray LLP

Beats Electronics, LLC
Attorney Name: Steven M. Balcof
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs
Attorney Name: David R. Kocan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Ruckus Networks
Attorney Name: David R. Kocan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Beats Electronics, LLC
Attorney Name: David R. Kocan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Stephen Joel Rosenman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Stephen Joel Rosenman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Stephen Joel Rosenman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Stephen Joel Rosenman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Tellabs
Attorney Name: Stephen Joel Rosenman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Ruckus Networks
Attorney Name: Stephen Joel Rosenman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Beats Electronics, LLC
Attorney Name: Stephen Joel Rosenman
Ropes & Gray LLP

United States House of Representatives
Attorney Name: Michael M. Honda
United States House of Representatives

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Emi Ito Ortiz
AMS Trade LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Sarah Elizabeth Hamblin
AMS Trade LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Qian Sheng
AMS Trade LLP

Beats Electronics, LLC
Attorney Name: Eric C. Rusnak
K&L Gates

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Joseph E. Van Tassel
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Lori Goodin
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Timothy O'Toole
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Jon Potler
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Jack Shaw
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Zach Hone
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Ken Kelch
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Renee Kelch
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Tai Lee
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Cappy Hallock
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Jose Rivera
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Andrea Ignacio
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Ramon Peraza
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: William Kerr
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Steven Pepe
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Peter S. Gwozdz
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Arwyn Carroll
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Jigang Jin
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Dalila A. Wendlandt
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Seung Woo Hur
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Meera Nair
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Joseph E. Van Tassel
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Joseph E. Van Tassel
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Joseph E. Van Tassel
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Lori Goodin
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Timothy O'Toole
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jon Potler
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jack Shaw
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Jack Shaw
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Jack Shaw
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Zach Hone
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Ken Kelch
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Renee Kelch
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Tai Lee
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Cappy Hallock
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jose Rivera
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Andrea Ignacio
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Ramon Peraza
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: William Kerr
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Steven Pepe
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Steven Pepe
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Steven Pepe
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Peter S. Gwozdz
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Arwyn Carroll
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Arwyn Carroll
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Arwyn Carroll
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jigang Jin
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Jigang Jin
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Jigang Jin
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Dalila A. Wendlandt
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Dalila A. Wendlandt
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Dalila A. Wendlandt
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Seung Woo Hur
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Seung Woo Hur
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Seung Woo Hur
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Meera Nair
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Meera Nair
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Meera Nair
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Jung-Hyun Uhm
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jung-Hyun Uhm
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Jung-Hyun Uhm
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Jung-Hyun Uhm
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Interna
Attorney Name: Paul M. Schoenhard
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Eric W. Chang
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Eric W. Chang
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Eric W. Chang
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Eric W. Chang
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Conor B. McDonough
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Conor B. McDonough
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Conor B. McDonough
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Conor B. McDonough
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Laurence S. Rogers
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Laurence S. Rogers
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Laurence S. Rogers
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Laurence S. Rogers
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: David R. Kocan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: David R. Kocan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: David R. Kocan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: David R. Kocan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Michael S. Heesters
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Michael S. Heesters
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Michael S. Heesters
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Michael S. Heesters
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Mark Daniel Rowland
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Mark Daniel Rowland
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Mark Daniel Rowland
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Mark Daniel Rowland
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Latonia Lewis
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Latonia Lewis
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Diana G. Santos
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Diana G. Santos
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Diana G. Santos
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Diana G. Santos
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Steven Baughman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Steven Baughman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Steven Baughman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Steven Baughman
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Michael P. Kahn
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Michael P. Kahn
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Michael P. Kahn
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Michael P. Kahn
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Thomas Szepesi
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Thomas Szepesi
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Brian P. Biddinger
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Brian P. Biddinger
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Janice V. Jabido
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Janice V. Jabido
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Matthew D. Buchanan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew D. Buchanan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Matthew D. Buchanan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Matthew D. Buchanan
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Gina H. Cremona
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Gina H. Cremona
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Gina H. Cremona
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Gina H. Cremona
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: James L. Davison
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: James L. Davison
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: James L. Davison
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: James L. Davison
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Jenna Marie Gillingham
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jenna Marie Gillingham
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Jenna Marie Gillingham
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Jenna Marie Gillingham
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Matthew J. McDonell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. McDonell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Matthew J. McDonell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Matthew J. McDonell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Matthew S. Paik
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew S. Paik
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Matthew S. Paik
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Matthew S. Paik
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Josef Schenker
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Josef Schenker
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Josef Schenker
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Josef Schenker
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Tom M. Schaumberg
AMS Trade LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Paul M. Bartkowski
AMS Trade LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Deborah S. Strauss
AMS Trade LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Rowan M. Dougherty
AMS Trade LLP

Delphi Automotive Systems LLC
Attorney Name: Evan H. Langdon
AMS Trade LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Alexander E. Middleton
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Alexander E. Middleton
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Alexander E. Middleton
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Alexander E. Middleton
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Andrew N. Thomases
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Andrew N. Thomases
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Andrew N. Thomases
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Andrew N. Thomases
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Brenner
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Brenner
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Brenner
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Samuel L. Brenner
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Ian B. Brooks
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Ian B. Brooks
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Ian B. Brooks
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Ian B. Brooks
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Evan F. Hiller
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Evan F. Hiller
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Evan F. Hiller
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Evan F. Hiller
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Nicole M. Jantzi
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Nicole M. Jantzi
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Nicole M. Jantzi
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Nicole M. Jantzi
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Megan F. Raymond
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Megan F. Raymond
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Megan F. Raymond
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Megan F. Raymond
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Jessica Spradling Russell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Jessica Spradling Russell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Jessica Spradling Russell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Jessica Spradling Russell
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Drew J. Schulte
Ropes & Gray LLP

Spansion (Thailand) Ltd.
Attorney Name: Drew J. Schulte
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman International Industries
Attorney Name: Drew J. Schulte
Ropes & Gray LLP

Harman Becker Automotive Systems GmbH
Attorney Name: Drew J. Schulte
Ropes & Gray LLP

Beats Electronics, LLC
Attorney Name: Michael J. Bettinger
K&L Gates

Spansion LLC
Attorney Name: Sarah Elizabeth Hamblin
AMS Trade LLP

Attorney Name: Christine Ezzell Singer
Ropes & Gray LLP

Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP

Attorney Name: Tom M. Schaumberg
AMS Trade LLP

Menu