Replacement Automotive Lamps II (Violation) > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-1292
Filing Date Dec 15, 2021
Docket Number 3584
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Jan 24, 2022
Markman Hearing Start Date -
Markman Hearing End Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Aug 18, 2022
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Aug 22, 2022
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date Aug 22, 2022
Target Date Mar 7, 2024
Final ID On Violation Due Date Oct 21, 2023
Final ID On Violation Issue Date Dec 1, 2022
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Jan 24, 2023
Final Determination of No Violation -
Final Determination of Violation Mar 7, 2024
Termination Date Mar 7, 2024
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Administrative JudgesClark Cheney
Active JudgeClark Cheney
Complainant
Respondent
4Complainant Attorneys
43Hyundai
Attorney Name: Philip A. Riley
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Guang Yu Zhu
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Robert A. Hall
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Ginger Robyn
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Manni Li
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Robert D. Wells
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Jeff Pearson
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Patrick Schiavone
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Craig Metros
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Amanda Lin
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Yugo Wang
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Paul M. Bartkowski
Bartkowski PLLC
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Thomas R. Burns
Bartkowski PLLC
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Emi Ito Ortiz
Bartkowski PLLC
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Laurence M. Sandell
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Edward Joel Naidich
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Kyongtaek K. Mun
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Lei Mei
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Robert G. Hall
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Jiwei Zhang
Mei & Mark
Hyundai
Attorney Name: James Pak
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Joseph M. Paunovich
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Kevin Chu
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Brett J. Arnold
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Jeffrey C. Y. Wu
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Rajat Khanna
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Ashle Page
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Courtney S. Kasuboski
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Gene K. Park
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: David Nelson
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Sean S. Pak
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Kevin Jang
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Philip A. Riley
Flynn, David
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Paul M. Bartkowski
BABIARZ, Joshua
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Lei Mei
Flynn, David
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Jiwei Zhang
Flynn, David
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Robert G. Hall
Flynn, David
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Kyongtaek K. Mun
Flynn, David
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Edward Joel Naidich
Flynn, David
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Laurence M. Sandell
Flynn, David
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Alex Lasher
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: William B. Adams
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Hyundai
Attorney Name: Ari Wugalter
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Respondent Attorneys
164LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Daniel Sokoloff
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Tom M. Schaumberg
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Nicholas K. Wheeler
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Nicholas K. Wheeler
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Daniel G. Zhang
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Daniel G. Zhang
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Leslie S. Johnson
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Leslie S. Johnson
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Kathleen Barney
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Kathleen Barney
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Daryl Baucum
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Daryl Baucum
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Bill Kim
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Bill Kim
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Myoung Sun Lim
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Myoung Sun Lim
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Mark McClure
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Mark McClure
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael Nranian
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Michael Nranian
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Rett Snotherly
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Rebekah Woods
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Rebekah Woods
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Todd W. Kunz
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Todd W. Kunz
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Jun Ma
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Jun Ma
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Ivan Wang
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Ivan Wang
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Michael Newell
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael Newell
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Daniel Ross
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Daniel Ross
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Robert B. Winter
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Robert B. Winter
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Deepa Sundararaman
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Deepa Sundararaman
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Kia Corporation
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
K & I INC.
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Christopher Todd Holland
Holland Law LLP
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Christopher Todd Holland
Holland Law LLP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Lori L. Holland
Holland Law LLP
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Lori L. Holland
Holland Law LLP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Pei Hsien Ren
Holland Law LLP
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Pei Hsien Ren
Holland Law LLP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Clark A. Waldon
Holland Law LLP
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Clark A. Waldon
Holland Law LLP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Hayley Ostrin
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Hayley Ostrin
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Catherine Mayer
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Catherine Mayer
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Barry Frederick Irwin
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Edward K. Runyan
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael P. Bregenzer
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Jason J. Keener
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Ted Mahan
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Andrew Y. Choi
Irwin IP
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Barry Frederick Irwin
Irwin IP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Barry Frederick Irwin
Irwin IP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: James W. Beard
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: James W. Beard
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Robyn M. Bowland
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Robyn M. Bowland
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Catherine Mayer
Merchant & Gould
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Catherine Mayer
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Lydia Zinn
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Lydia Zinn
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Melissa Kuylen
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Melissa Kuylen
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: To Allowthe Cross-Usediscovery
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: To Allowthe Cross-Usediscovery
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: To Allowthe Cross-Usediscovery
Merchant & Gould
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: To Allowthe Cross-Usediscovery
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Brian M. Baker
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Brian M. Baker
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Young Moo Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Young Moo Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Soonmee Kwon-Lee
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Soonmee Kwon-Lee
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Annie Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Annie Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Andrea Ignacio
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Andrea Ignacio
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Matthew Sculatti
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Matthew Sculatti
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Sue Mi Jones
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Sue Mi Jones
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Hongmook Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Hongmook Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Annie Lee
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Annie Lee
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Joe Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Joe Kim
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Hyesun S. Lee
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Hyesun S. Lee
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Julie Wagner
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Julie Wagner
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: John T. Winemiller
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: John T. Winemiller
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Marty Koresawa
Holland Law LLP
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Marty Koresawa
Holland Law LLP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Peter Selness
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Peter Selness
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Elisabeth S. Muirhead
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Elisabeth S. Muirhead
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Rett Snotherly
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Rett Snotherly
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael P. Bregenzer
Irwin IP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Michael P. Bregenzer
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Drew Montemarano
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Drew Montemarano
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Dustin T. Dutchuk
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Dustin T. Dutchuk
Irwin IP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Kristen M. Souther
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Kristen M. Souther
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: John Ward
Holland Law LLP
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: John Ward
Holland Law LLP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Michael A. Erbele
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Michael A. Erbele
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Una Wilkinson
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Una Wilkinson
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Christopher D. Eggert
LKQ Corporation
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Edward J. Mahan
Irwin IP
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Michael P. Bregenzer
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Edward K. Runyan
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Jason J. Keener
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Daniel Sokoloff
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Ted Mahan
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Tom M. Schaumberg
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Rett Snotherly
Levi Snotherly & Schaumberg, PLLC
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Andrew Y. Choi
Irwin IP
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Barry Frederick Irwin
Irwin IP
LKQ Corporation
Attorney Name: Hanna Kim
Veritext Legal Solutions
Kia Motors America
Attorney Name: Joshua A. Hartman
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Jason Wiener
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Jason Wiener
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Bridget Carmichael Greene
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Bridget Carmichael Greene
Merchant & Gould
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Nathan Ira Finkelstein
Merchant & Gould
Genera Corporation
Attorney Name: Nathan Ira Finkelstein
Merchant & Gould
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Benjamin Levi
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Ted Mahan
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Jason J. Keener
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Edward K. Runyan
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Daniel Sokoloff
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Michael P. Bregenzer
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Rett Snotherly
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Tom M. Schaumberg
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Andrew Y. Choi
Keystone Automotive Operations Inc
Attorney Name: Barry Frederick Irwin
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Pei Hsien Ren
Selim, Mohammed
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: Christopher Todd Holland
Selim, Mohammed
TYC Brother Industrial Co.
Attorney Name: John Ward
Selim, Mohammed
