Smart Thermostat Systems, Smart HVAC Systems, Smart HVAC Control Systems, And Components Thereof > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-1258
Filing Date Feb 26, 2021
Docket Number 3535
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Apr 2, 2021
Markman Hearing Start Date -
Markman Hearing End Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Dec 13, 2021
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Dec 17, 2021
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date Dec 17, 2021
Target Date Aug 2, 2022
Final ID On Violation Due Date Apr 4, 2022
Final ID On Violation Issue Date -
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Apr 4, 2022
Final Determination of No Violation -
Final Determination of Violation Jun 22, 2022
Termination Date Jun 22, 2022
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Administrative JudgesCameron Elliot
Active JudgeCameron Elliot
Complainant
Respondent
13Complainant Attorneys
21EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew D. Aichele
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Reza Mirzaie
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Marc A. Fenster
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Chang Jay Y. Chung
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kristopher R. Davis
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: James N. Pickens
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Minna Y. Jay
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jason Wietholter
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jonathan D. Link
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Erik De La Iglesia
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Nikolaus Baer
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Robert Zeidman
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Pierre Kressmann
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: James D. Beall
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Karine Beers
Digital Evidence Group
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Julie Wright
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Jeffrey Nichols
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Adam S. Hoffman
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Drew Mooney
Russ August & Kabat
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Mary J. Boswell
Venable
EcoFactor, Inc.
Attorney Name: Chang Jay Y. Chung
Russ August & Kabat
Respondent Attorneys
101Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Stephen A. Marshall
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Carrier
Attorney Name: Joon Chung
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Betty H. Chen
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Aamir A. Kazi
Fish & Richardson
Resideo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: M. Scott Stevens
Alston & Bird
Honeywell International
Attorney Name: M. Scott Stevens
Alston & Bird
Resideo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: S. Benjamin Pleune
Alston & Bird
Honeywell International
Attorney Name: S. Benjamin Pleune
Alston & Bird
Resideo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen R. Lareau
Alston & Bird
Honeywell International
Attorney Name: Stephen R. Lareau
Alston & Bird
Resideo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Adam J. Doane
Alston & Bird
Honeywell International
Attorney Name: Adam J. Doane
Alston & Bird
Resideo Technologies, Inc.
Attorney Name: Lauren Nichole Griffin
Alston & Bird
Honeywell International
Attorney Name: Lauren Nichole Griffin
Alston & Bird
Emerson Electric Co.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Rizzolo
Ropes & Gray LLP
Carrier
Attorney Name: Ruffin B. Cordell
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Thomas S. Fusco
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Michael F. Autuoro
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Scott M. Flanz
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Jeanel N. Sunga
Fish & Richardson
Google
Attorney Name: Bijal V. Vakil
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: James Gagen
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: Daniel S. Sternberg
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: Henry Y. Huang
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: Emily Lipka
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: Jacob M. Rothenberg
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: Grace I. Wang
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: David A. Markoff
White & Case
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Timothy J. Carroll
Dentons
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Steven M. Lubezny
Dentons
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Catherine N. Taylor
Dentons
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Manny Joseph Caixeiro
Dentons
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Kirk R. Ruthenberg
Dentons
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Indranil Mukerji
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Devon W. Edwards
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Leigh Coutoumanos
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Jessica Blanton
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Mitchell M. Feldhake
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Steve Taylor
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Google
Attorney Name: Carla Mulhern
White & Case
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Carla Mulhern
White & Case
Carrier
Attorney Name: Carla Mulhern
White & Case
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Carla Mulhern
White & Case
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Richard M. Goodin
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Elizabeth M. Manno
Dentons
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Diana Curtis
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Megan S. Woodworth
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: Megan S. Woodworth
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: Victoria A. Moffa
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: Duncan S. Callaway
White & Case
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Daniel A. Apgar
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: David Auslander
White & Case
Google
Attorney Name: Ginger D. Anders
Munger Tolles & Olson
Google
Attorney Name: Vincent Y. Ling
Munger Tolles & Olson
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Alex Miller
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: Yuval Newman
TrialGraphix, Inc.
Google
Attorney Name: Ian Andryszak
TrialGraphix, Inc.
Google
Attorney Name: Kerry P. Cashman
TrialGraphix, Inc.
Google
Attorney Name: Anthony Canzanella
TrialGraphix, Inc.
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Barbara Lucente
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Andrea Lewis
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Josh Splansky
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Celyra I. Workman
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Nicolas Batara
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Zachary M. Lochner
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Matthew Pooley
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Laura Popa
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Gavin Scott
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Shukri Souri
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: Megan Ines
A&O Shearman
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Margaret K. Ukwu
Venable
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Vivian Sandoval
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: Eric E. Lancaster
A&O Shearman
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Leslie A. Lee
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: Michelle E. Wang
A&O Shearman
Google
Attorney Name: James N. Reed
A&O Shearman
Google
Attorney Name: Shamita D. Etienne-Cummings
A&O Shearman
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Shamita D. Etienne-Cummings
A&O Shearman
Ecobee
Attorney Name: Abby Marie Neu
Venable
Google
Attorney Name: David Nickel
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Google
Attorney Name: Barbara A. Murphy
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Google
Attorney Name: James B. Altman
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Google
Attorney Name: Matthew Duescher
Foster, Murphy, Altman & Nickel, PC
Google
Attorney Name: Alan M. Billharz
A&O Shearman
Google
Attorney Name: Brendan B. Gants
Munger Tolles & Olson
Google
Attorney Name: Shamita D. Etienne-Cummings
A&O Shearman
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Stephen A. Marshall
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Carrier
Attorney Name: Aamir A. Kazi
Fish & Richardson
Emerson Electric Co.
Attorney Name: James R. Batchelder
Ropes & Gray LLP
Emerson Electric Co.
Attorney Name: James L. Davis Jr.
Ropes & Gray LLP
Emerson Electric Co.
Attorney Name: Daniel W. Richards
Ropes & Gray LLP
Emerson Electric Co.
Attorney Name: Evan Mann
Ropes & Gray LLP
Carrier
Attorney Name: Ruffin B. Cordell
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Michael F. Autuoro
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Joon Chung
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Jeanel N. Sunga
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Thomas S. Fusco
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Scott M. Flanz
Fish & Richardson
Carrier
Attorney Name: Betty H. Chen
Fish & Richardson
Johnson Controls
Attorney Name: Jessica Blanton
Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Attorney Name: Alexandra Loew
Russ August & Kabat
Related Patents
Doc No | Title | Issue date |
---|---|---|
10612983 | System and method for evaluating changes in the efficiency of an HVAC system | Apr 7, 2020 |
08886488 | System and method for calculating the thermal mass of a building | Nov 11, 2014 |
08596550 | System, method and apparatus for identifying manual inputs to and adaptive programming of a thermostat | Dec 3, 2013 |
08423322 | System and method for evaluating changes in the efficiency of an HVAC system | Apr 16, 2013 |
08019567 | System and method for evaluating changes in the efficiency of an HVAC system | Sep 13, 2011 |