Vehicle Security and Remote Convenience Systems and Components Thereof > Summary
Court Case Number 337-TA-1152
Filing Date Mar 5, 2019
Docket Number 3370
Investigation Type Violation
Unfair Act Patent Infringement
Institution Date Apr 10, 2019
Markman Hearing Start Date -
Markman Hearing End Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled Start Date Jan 27, 2020
Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled End Date Jan 31, 2020
Evidentiary Hearing Actual Start Date -
Evidentiary Hearing Actual End Date -
Target Date Aug 10, 2020
Final ID On Violation Due Date Apr 10, 2020
Final ID On Violation Issue Date -
Non Final (Terminating) ID Issued Jan 31, 2020
Final Determination of No Violation Feb 28, 2020
Final Determination of Violation -
Termination Date Feb 28, 2020
Court International Trade Commission
Status Terminated
Administrative JudgesSandra Lord
Active JudgeSandra Lord
Complainant Attorneys
84DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Scaife
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Elizabeth Shrieves
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Sarah E. Moore
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Smith
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Brigham
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Emily Elizabeth Terrell
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Scaife
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Scaife
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Elizabeth Shrieves
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Elizabeth Shrieves
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Sarah E. Moore
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sarah E. Moore
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Smith
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Stephen Smith
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Brigham
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Matthew J. Brigham
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Emily Elizabeth Terrell
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Emily Elizabeth Terrell
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Samuel K. Whitt
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Samuel K. Whitt
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Vamsi K. Gottipati
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Vamsi K. Gottipati
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Vamsi K. Gottipati
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Amit Gupta
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Amit Gupta
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Amit Gupta
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Palash Kacholia
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Palash Kacholia
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Palash Kacholia
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher K. Wilson
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher K. Wilson
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Christopher K. Wilson
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian R. Nester
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Brian R. Nester
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael R. Franzinger
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael R. Franzinger
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul J. Zegger
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Paul J. Zegger
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Hamilton C. Simpson
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Hamilton C. Simpson
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Michael R. Franzinger
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Kenny Flanagan
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Kenny Flanagan
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Liz Borrelli
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Liz Borrelli
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Timothy Hunter
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Timothy Hunter
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Cherie Klein
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Cherie Klein
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Joseph Blain
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joseph Blain
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: David Oxilia
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: David Oxilia
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshua J. Fougere
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshua J. Fougere
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Joshua J. Fougere
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Laura Ashley Harris
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Laura Ashley Harris
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Laura Ashley Harris
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: David Manzo
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: David Manzo
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: David Manzo
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: John Wissenbach
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: John Wissenbach
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: John Wissenbach
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Curtis A. Evans
TrialGraphix, Inc.
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Curtis A. Evans
TrialGraphix, Inc.
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Curtis A. Evans
TrialGraphix, Inc.
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Adam Kleven
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Adam Kleven
Sidley Austin
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Adam Kleven
Sidley Austin
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Sarah B. Moore
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Mary Viguie
Cooley LLP
DEI Holdings Inc.
Attorney Name: Scott Andrews
Cooley LLP
Attorney Name: Samuel K. Whitt
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Palash Kacholia
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Vamsi K. Gottipati
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Scott Andrews
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Amit Gupta
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Thomas D. Vander Veen
Cooley LLP
Directed Electronics, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sarah B. Moore
Cooley LLP
Respondent Attorneys
57Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Joseph Trojan
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Jeffrey M. Telep
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Jeffrey M. Telep
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Kevin Andrew Lake
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Kevin Andrew Lake
King & Spalding
AAMP Global
Attorney Name: Dennis P. Waggoner
Hill Ward Henderson, PA
FIRSTTECH INCORPORATION
Attorney Name: Joseph Trojan
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Nathalie P. Smith
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Christopher C. Campbell
King & Spalding
AAMP Global
Attorney Name: David L. Luikart III
Hill Ward Henderson, PA
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Dylan C. Dang
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Francis Wong
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: John D. Roehrick
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Richard Carl Salfelder
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Nathalie P. Smith
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Christopher C. Campbell
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Dylan C. Dang
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Francis Wong
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: John D. Roehrick
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Richard Carl Salfelder
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Evan S. Kovanis
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Evan S. Kovanis
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Ryan Herrington
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Ryan Herrington
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Britton F. Davis
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Britton F. Davis
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Angela Campbell Tarasi
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Angela Campbell Tarasi
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Jeffrey David Mills
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Jeffrey David Mills
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Lida Ramsey
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Lida Ramsey
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Brent P. Ray
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Brent P. Ray
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Jonathan Weinberg
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Jonathan Weinberg
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Michael Briggs
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Michael Briggs
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Mehran Khatchadorian
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Mehran Khatchadorian
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Felicia Newland
King & Spalding
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Felicia Newland
King & Spalding
AAMP Global
Attorney Name: Dennis P. Waggoner
Hill Ward Henderson, PA
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Dylan C. Dang
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Francis Wong
Trojan Law Offices
AAMP Global
Attorney Name: David L. Luikart III
Hill Ward Henderson, PA
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: John D. Roehrick
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Richard Carl Salfelder
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Joseph Trojan
Trojan Law Offices
Firstech LLC
Attorney Name: Mary Viguie
Cooley LLP
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Jeffrey M. Telep
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Christopher C. Campbell
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Christopher C. Campbell
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Jonathan Weinberg
King & Spalding
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Ryan Herrington
Trojan Law Offices
Automotive Technologies International
Attorney Name: Evan S. Kovanis
Trojan Law Offices
Related Patents
| Doc No | Title | Issue date |
|---|---|---|
| 08378800 | Security system and method for operating the same | Feb 19, 2013 |
| 07893386 | Laser micromachining and methods of same | Feb 22, 2011 |
| 07646285 | Security and remote access for vehicular safety and convenience systems | Jan 12, 2010 |
| 07483783 | Remote starting system for a vehicle | Jan 27, 2009 |
| 07191053 | Remote starting system for a vehicle | Mar 13, 2007 |
