Patexia Research

Case number IPR2015-01481

Lawsuits

International Business Machines Corporation v. Intellectual Ventures I LLC > Summary

Court Case Number IPR2015-01481

Filing Date Jun 23, 2015

Institution Decision Date Jan 11, 2016

Decision Date Jan 9, 2017

Court Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Status Final Written Decision

Appeal2017-1788

Administrative JudgesMeredith C. Petravick, Jennifer S. Bisk, Sheila F. McShane

Judge Writing the Final DecisionMeredith C. Petravick

Claims Challenged in the Petition: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 12, 14, 16

Claims Instituted: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6

Claims Invalidated: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6

Petitioner

International Business Machines

Patent Owner

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

Petitioner Attorneys

4

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Eugene Goryunov
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Joel R. Merkin
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Brent P. Ray
Kirkland & Ellis

International Business Machines
Attorney Name: Kenneth R. Adamo
Kirkland & Ellis

Patent Owner Attorneys

17

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: James R. Hietala
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Tim R. Seeley
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Q. Todd Dickinson
Polsinelli

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Henry August Petri
Polsinelli

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: James P. Murphy
Polsinelli

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Donald J. Coulman
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Q. Todd Dickinson
Novak Druce Carroll, LLP

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Henry August Petri
Novak Druce Carroll, LLP

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: James P. Murphy
Novak Druce Carroll, LLP

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Donald J. Coulman
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: James R. Hietala
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Tim R. Seeley
Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Q. Todd Dickinson
Polsinelli

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: Henry August Petri
Polsinelli

Intellectual Ventures Management, LLC
Attorney Name: James P. Murphy
Polsinelli

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Douglas Bowman
Polsinelli

I.D. Systems, Inc.
Attorney Name: Sabrina Alaniz
Polsinelli

Related Patents

Doc No	Title	Issue date
06510434	System and method for retrieving information from a database using an index of XML tags and metafiles	Jan 21, 2003